#app_203810_short_desc
Recenzii utilizatori: În mare parte Pozitive (3,903 recenzii)
Data lansării: 14 feb., 2012

Loghează-te pentru a adăuga acest joc în lista ta de dorinţe sau marchează-l dacă nu eşti interesat.

Cumpără Dear Esther

Cumpără Dear Esther + Soundtrack

 

Recomandat de Curatori

"Not for everyone, I realise, but as an example of games trying Something Else, I think Dear Esther is hard to argue against."
Citeşte întreaga recenzie aici.

Despre acest joc

#auto_app_203810_about_default

Cerinţe de sistem

Windows
Mac OS X
    #sys_req_203810_min
    #sys_req_203810_rec
    #auto_app_203810_sysreq_mac_default
Recenzii utile ale clienților
42 din 50 oameni (84%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
4.3 ore înregistrate
Postat: 10 noiembrie
Dear Esther: Games as Art

Up till five years ago, discussions about games as a form of art, were largely considered as non-important. There was a more or less clear distinction between the "higher" arts, and the more "commercial" games, although many of those used elements from several arts (in-game music, often symphonic and with a classical feel to it, being just one example). With the rise of the Indie game-scene around 2010, things started to evolve fast. Since indie-developers are not bound by contracts to large (and indeed often very commercial) publishers, they found themselves in a position where experimenting with the medium of games itself turned into something viable.

One of the almost immediate consequences of this huge shift in focus, was the rise of what many have called since then "artistic games": games as the newest form of art, following in the footsteps of literature, music, architecture, painting, sculpture, photography, cinematography and the likes. This idea has generated some debate during the last five years, but it's still an underrated aspect of gaming. The one game that really stands out as maybe thé flagship of the artistic games, would surely be Dear Esther. Released in February 2012 by the small indie-company The Chinese Room, it made a huge impact on the gaming scene by the radical way in which it changes the entire concept of what a computer game is all about.

In this game there are no "goals" the player has to achieve, there is no such thing as "winning or losing", there is not even the possibility of playing well or badly, or of interacting with the environment. Actually, the gameplay is extremely limited: the player can only walk around on an abandoned island in the Scottish Hebrides in first-person view, with no running, jumping, climbing or crouching as in most first-person games. This immediately gives the game a very leisured pace, which may not be to the liking of everyone. Dear Esther has even been called a "walking simulator" - it's the most prominent of its tags on the Steam store at the moment. But it's nothing like that, in my opinion. Thsi game is not about the physical walk around the - extremely impressive and atmospheric - island. Dear Esther tells another kind of story: a story that happens within the main character, and one that is told with such emotional force that I as a player not only identified myself with the character, but also started to actually FEEL like he does. Now that's a rare experience in any game up till now: the feeling that the entire game, with all its components (visuals, story, music in this case) got under my skin in such a way that I got emotionally involved to a very, very large extent. I won't spoil anything from the story, but it's nothing light-weight to be sure and the game has stayed with me since I first played it three weeks ago.

And there is not really much more to say about this amazing, almost genre-defining piece of art. Actually, the debate may not be if it's a piece of art (most will agree to that), but to whether it's a game or not. To my opinion, it's certainly both, and as such stands proud as one of the prime examples of artistic games that give as rich and rewarding an experience as reading a novel by Daphne du Maurier, looking at a painting by Turner or listening to a sonata by Mozart. But be advised: this gem calls for your complete attention, so headphones and a dark environment are recommended. Especially so since the soundscape the game provides, be it from the howling of the wind to the eerie, haunting music by Jessica Curry, deserves every inch of attention.

Overall score: 9/10
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
18 din 21 oameni (86%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
2.5 ore înregistrate
Postat: 4 noiembrie
"How many dead shepherds could fill this hole?"

Dear Esther is the kind of video game which is doomed to be criticized. The reason is gameplay for you only do three things: walk, listen and watch. Formula like this can encouraged a decent number of people to confer a title of Walking Simulator - 2012 on this adventure game from the young British developer The Chinese Room , who previously worked on the atmospheric Half-Life 2 mod Korsakovia. But at this point gamers of all ages should ask themselves a question: do they need another rank-and-file FPS on already flooded modern VG market or are they open for innovative ideas and blending of various kinds of art?

Dear Esther originated from a Source engine mod of the same name made by The Chinese Room in 2008. In this completely reworked standalone only WASD and a mouse are required to play (get your left-hand middle finger ready). Taking into consideration this fact, if Dear Esther was the first video game ever made by man, the industry would have been slightly different... However, alternate history theories aside, DE is to be considered as an unusual experiment, which strays from traditional principles of electronic entertainment. Gameplay is stripped of some now widespread features: interactive objects, logs, and puzzles. It takes away the fun in a traditional sense of the word though it may be all this have been sacrificed for the sake of storytelling and getting more engaging and emotion-focused experience.

The storyline is one of the strongest points of the title. Presented in a form of an audio messages, it tells about the man who lives (lived?) as a hermit on an island in the Hebrides - an archipelago just off the coast of Scotland. He wrote a letter to Esther, supposedly his wife, and messages you hear exploring as an unnamed silent protagonist are clippings from this writing. They appear when you reach certain spots of four different locations. This feature adds some replay value to a mature, if rather short journey as one can discover new pieces of the story should he visit places he missed in the next play-through. Writing is top-notch, the narrator is brilliant and reminds of the great Richard Burton, who lent his voice for Jeff Wayne's 1978 epic rock opera War of the Worlds. The story raises some major existential questions, leaves room for interpretation, and overall feels like it has been inspired by H.P. Lovecraft works.

Dear Esther looks and sounds gorgeous. It is not about photo-realistic visuals but about crafty game of light and dark, sounds, colors, and shapes. The island feels alive: grass sways, water flows, caves breathe and glimmer. The result: the most impressive landscapes which are competing in one league with Dead Space franchise and Skyrim. Sound design is faithfully backing it all up as everything - from chilly wind to distant ship horns - sounds naturally yet somehow unusual, out of this world. Combined with serene, at times dreadful music by Jessica Curry, it makes a huge impact, immersing one into the atmosphere.

Giving the game credit where credit's due, it is more than just a bold experiment. Dear Esther is an indie title which shows that gaming has grown up and is not just about mashing buttons and shooting galleries anymore. It offers no challenge but challenges your mind. It doesn't pull of any tricks but occupies it's own niche and broadens the boundaries of PC gaming, thereby bringing rage upon itself. For $10 you get 2 hours of sheer aesthetic joy on your PC. Only if your slogan is "No gameplay, no game", there is nothing for you here and there will never be.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
10 din 12 oameni (83%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
9.5 ore înregistrate
Postat: 15 noiembrie
This is an excellent way to share some time with yourself, in a very intimate way. Only for loners.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
15 din 25 oameni (60%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
2.2 ore înregistrate
Postat: 28 octombrie
My recommendation to anyone thinking about playing this game is to go into it with the proper mindset. It is not so much a game in the traditionally understood sense of the word. Rather, Dear Esther is an almost entirely cerebral experience. It works on the player in much the same way a good painting will effect an observer who sees in the art not merely a window looking out on our own world, but that same world slightly altered by the surreal, and thus bringing to light things about ourselves we might not otherwise see. That said, Dear Esther, by it's very poetic nature, is one of the most immediately captivating games I have encountered; I do not believe it should be overlooked simply because it does not conform to the usual way in which people have come to view video games.

Overwhelming is the sense of solitude on this gloomy, desolate Hebridean island. Heavier still is the desperately sorrowful soundtrack, by Jessica Curry. In style, it is similar to film composer Christopher Young's most sparsely written music, and plays as a more effective voice in this introspective journey than does the admittedly potent narrator. I often find game music lacking in its ability to plunge beneath the fabric of a game and tug to light its individual and vibrantly beating heart, but this is a rare instance where such a feat is accomplished. Haunting as any chamber music has ever been, the score to Dear Esther will probe the emptiness within each of us, and get us contemplating questions most prefer to ignore.

This is a relatively short journey, requiring the gamer to simply progress across the island until they have reached a lone radio mast. There are no decisions to be made, no objects to interact with, and the fragmented narration of the main character plays out as you progress. The epistolary narrative renders the intent of the story in a vague light, like a sequence of events seen through shimmering tears. It is debatable what Dear Esther is actually trying to say (and I believe it to have been done that way intentionally), but anyone willing to open themselves to the voices haunting this Scottish island are certain to draw some very strong conclusions.

To me, the story deals primarily with unspeakable loss, and how we set ourselves up for even greater heartache (potentially leading even to madness) if God is not our anchor in all things. I, for one, see the issue of personal transcendence (as it is articulated at the end of the game by the main character's leap from the radio tower, who then begins a ghostly flight across the moon-dappled sea, followed by a black fade) to be illustrative not of our ability to achieve such a spiritual shift on our own, but exactly the opposite: There exists within fallen humanity a perpetual, aching cry to be delivered, redeemed--to transcend the shattering effects of our sinful natures.... But humanism cannot accomplish this miracle, nor any form of man-centered religion focusing on personal moral performance or upon the sincerity of their emotions as they are connected to a certain belief system. The blood of the Lord Jesus Christ is the only atonement by which we can be saved from all this death. He is the only peace, the only Truth. The end result of all other efforts at redemption lead only to chilly shadows and vacuous spaces brimming with regret.

Hopefully sharing my personal interpretation of Dear Esther does not come across as a clumsy effort to proselytize (if that were the case, I would certainly have given the Gospel in its fullness), but rather illustrates the power and versatility the player can expect to experience by such an unconventional game as this.

For anyone looking to plunge beneath the surface within themselves as they embark upon the solitary journey to the radio tower, Dear Esther offers surprising treasures that periodically flash their brilliance even years after the experience has ended.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
15 din 25 oameni (60%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.4 ore înregistrate
Postat: 30 octombrie
Definitely the best walking simulator out there i'd say
10/10
would walk again
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
4 din 5 oameni (80%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
4.1 ore înregistrate
Postat: 8 noiembrie
Ever noticed how, very occasionally, you will play a game, listen to a piece of music, watch a movie or whatever, and you know, as soon as you've finished that it will stay with you for a long time?
I'm getting that right now.

I've just played through Dear Esther twice and I find it to be time and money VERY well spent.
This is not a game in the conventional sense.
If your fix is usually space marines shooting aliens, this might not be for you. It is very unorthodox.

It has no enemies, no other characters, no items, no object interaction at all. All you do is walk and explore as the back story unfolds through often dreamy monologues.
But therein lies its strength. It really does try something different, and it pays off.

It really is beautiful. It's a couple of years old now, but if you crank the settings up to full it really shines. This is due in large part to the actual art direction and creation of the island setting. It looks very natural with no copy and paste going on and it all takes place in dusk or night time so it looks moody and washed out.
Seriously, take time to look around at the scenery.

The sound is completely perfect and enhances the experience no-end.
The musical score is haunting and perfectly timed to coincide with epic scenery or other happenings. The narrator (the only voice in the 'game') does an excellent job as well.

It's a strange thing that a game in which you do so little can have such an impact, but that really is the case for me.
This game is as beautiful/haunting/mysterious as it is unorthodox.
It won't be for everyone, but if you are open to something different, put those headphones on, turn out the lights and go for a walk :-)
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 1 oameni (100%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.8 ore înregistrate
Postat: 25 noiembrie
This is a great, short, enthralling game. Well-written, excellent soundtrack, preconception-busting (unless you already have an opinion about the game, which you probably do).
One complaint: for a game that depends so much on walking to trigger audio exposition, it was awfully hard to tell where to go next. That much aimless wandering didn't really fit the story the game was trying to tell. Still worthwhile, though. More games like this please!
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 1 oameni (100%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.1 ore înregistrate
Postat: 25 noiembrie
Let me start with, yes, I do recommend this game. However, most people who play games these days are not like me, and may feel bored by a game like this. I should also say that this almost isn't a game, per se, due to it's lack of actual interaction with anything. I would define it as a simple walking simulator with a great story, beautiful music, and amazing visual art & graphics. If you're an artsy person, or someone who appreciates art, then you will enjoy this game. I hope to see more of this style in the future!
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 1 oameni (100%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
0.4 ore înregistrate
Postat: 25 noiembrie
I got bored and never finished it. The art's good, sure, but being on the source engine really holds it back from being something special.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
2 din 3 oameni (67%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.8 ore înregistrate
Postat: 7 noiembrie
I was utterly taken with this game from the moment I started playing it. The minimalistic soundtrack and utter freedom you are given to wander as you wish entranced me throughout the short time I played it. The narrator speaks as though reading poetry, though I questioned throughout the sanity of the narrator. Grief can do funny things to a person...
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
3 din 5 oameni (60%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
0.5 ore înregistrate
Postat: 23 noiembrie
As everyone should know, this is not a game but more of a story you walkthrough. That being said...it is a rather terrible story and not worth your time.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
11 din 21 oameni (52%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.1 ore înregistrate
Postat: 14 noiembrie
I play games to experience a story. This game made me take an excruatingly slow walk with some guy who is seemingly really high. Would not recommend unless you enjoy said activity.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
4 din 8 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
0.3 ore înregistrate
Postat: 12 noiembrie
If you're looking for a good story with a wide breadth of immersiveness, multiple layers of events and dailogue, clever detailing, pacing, prose, good characters, setting, and imaginitive visuals and imagery, then listen to my advice. Pick up a novel off your bookshelf. Sit down with a nice coffee on your favorite peice of furnature and seize the day. This game needs to be substantially better in every aspect for it to a. achieve what its creators likely envisioned and b. be worth your time & money.

This would only appeal to people with lack of good literature or similar slower paced or more punctilious media in their lives. I really don't see what the big deal is, maybe the people playing this game are really stoned.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 2 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.1 ore înregistrate
Postat: 22 noiembrie
Consider the price just a ticket for a touching, beautiful experience. Just download this, play it for 60 minutes and get on with your life. You will have one more story in your heart.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
2 din 4 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
0.6 ore înregistrate
Postat: 13 noiembrie
This is not a game for everyone sure the graphics are fantastic but at the end of the day it's an interactive movie with very little interaction other then walking.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 2 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.1 ore înregistrate
Postat: 16 noiembrie
I'm torn with this...game. As other reviewers have stated, it's not really a game. For me it was more an experience. The music is wonderful and adds perfectly to the atmosphere. There were moments on the journey that I was lost in this other world. When I looked up from my computer I was back in my crummy apartment.
It wasn't until the final chapter that I really had a problem. I fell into the water and my game froze, though the sound kept going. Normally you would just be brought back but I never was. I exited to the menu to start from the final chapter and it wouldn't let me. In fact, it would only select the first chapter. Really? I spent all that time and I can't even finish it!?
So wonderful experience but that fatal flaw just didn't make it worthwhile in the end.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 2 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.4 ore înregistrate
Postat: 21 noiembrie
For me this was not worth the money spent. There was nothing to do but walk around and listen to the narrator's somewhat poetic story and musical accompaniment. For those expecting a game in which there is something to do, with some reward at the end, I do not recommend this game.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
2 din 4 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
1.2 ore înregistrate
Postat: 22 noiembrie
good thing i didnt buy it
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 2 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
2.1 ore înregistrate
Postat: 23 noiembrie
This is a tough game for me to recommmend, would love it there was a 'Neutral' button on Steam. It's beautiful and the music is amazing, but the game feels shallow. The ending is nice, but it comes after slowly walking for 90+ minutes.

The last chapter feels most enjoyable, I'm not sure who would want to play through the first two though to get to that point honestly.

Suggestions for improvement

- Keep the user engaged more consistently through the narrartion. More talking, even if it's minor thoughts.
- Interactions. Something to feel like you're actually engaged in the world
- Make it more linear, if the point is pushing the story forward and the are no 'Easter Eggs' or 'rewards' for exploring make it so someone can't 'Get Lost'
- Subtitles - Could be more interesting, could be used as typograhic art that scrolls or changes in size and font to fit the mood. They felt drab and did little for immersion, so I turned them off
- Abilty to walk faster...jog even. Less of an issue if it was more linear, but going 'The wrong Way' then back tracking is tiresome here
- Camera: Make more dynamic, small bobbing as the character walks
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu
1 din 2 oameni (50%) consideră această recenzie folositoare
0.4 ore înregistrate
Postat: 23 noiembrie
No gameplay whatsoever. I got bored very quickly.
A fost această recenzie folositoare? Da Nu