Broken Age es perfectamente consciente de que hoy la calidad de una aventura gráfica ya no depende de la dificultad de sus acertijos y, en este sentido, constituye el enésimo intento de adaptar una fórmula que es ante todo fruto de una época a los tiempos modernos y al perfil del usuario actual. Ahí están los puzles sencillos bajo una cuidada estética cartoon, pero también esa complicidad con el jugador marca de la casa. La broma que sólo tipos como Tim Schafer saben colocar en el momento y en el lugar correctos. Justo cuando uno se da cuenta de que lo que más necesitaba era reír.

Más risas me ha procurado el episodio de Vella, la chica, pero creo que el inconformismo y la negación del destino de que tratan ambas historias están narrados de manera más eficaz e interesante en la de Shay.
Aunque es pronto para emitir un veredicto definitivo acerca de una obra que se distribuye en formato episódico, no me ha decepcionado este primer acto de Broken Age, ni mucho menos, pero tampoco lo considero como algo especialmente brillante. Agradable es la palabra que mejor casa con lo que sientes mientras lo juegas y curiosidad por el futuro de ambos protagonistas la que mejor define tu estado de ánimo al finalizarla. Ya veremos.

"La primer aventura gráfica de Tim Schafer en 16 años" es la frase principal en las descripción de este juego. En lo personal soy relativamente nuevo en el género de "Point and Click", pero he jugado algunos clásicos como Broken Sword, Loom y Maniac Mansion, por lo que tengo una pequeña referencia de lo que solía ser el género en su época de oro.

Broken Age cuenta con un estilo de arte excepcional y que verás muy poco en cualquier otro género, la historia te atrapa, y al final te deja un poco para atar cabos sueltos en la historia; probablemente no encuentres conexión entre ambas historias o te rompes la cabeza buscando cómo podrían llegar a entrecruzarse (como me ocurrió a mí).

No recordaba que éste era el tan prometido título de Double Fine que rompió records en crowd-funding y que anunciaban con tanto bombo y platillo (hype). Siendo justos, al compararlo con algunos juegos del género no tan viejos, los acertijos son demasiado simples, o puede ser que se simplifiquen si has jugado juegos más complejos como Tales of Monkey Island (Telltale Games) en donde las respuestas no son para nada obvias y hay qué romperse la cabeza por horas (piano en Silent Hill, alguien?).

Comparado con otros juegos es demasiado corto, podría ser comparable a un solo episodio del juego de Back to the Future que en sí era un juego fácil. Hay quienes rumoran que la segunda parte se venderá por separado y hay quienes creen que la segunda parte será gratuita, pero solo queda esperar, pues no ha habido respuesta del estudio a pesar de obtener casi 10 veces la cantidad originalmente solicitada en Kickstarter, que al parecer les ha servido para financiar otros múltiples títulos.

En resumen: si eres fan del género desde sus inicios, no es algo que valga la pena comprar si no es en una oferta, pues de donde viene el juego un esperaría algo más complejo o mínimo más extenso; si te llama la atención el género, es un buen título para comenzar.

Broken Age no es una aventura gráfica desternillante como las anteriores de Tim Schafer. Esta vez nos encontramos con un cuento amable y visualmente bello que nos sabe sumergir en su ambiente, y donde la sencillez y magia sobrepasan la pantalla. Parece que a Double Fine no le ha hecho falta basarse en las aventuras gráficas que atrajeron a la mayoría de sus Backers, y han sabido desmarcarse con un nueva y original propuesta. Análisis completo de Broken Age en La Fortaleza de LeChuck

Nice game, or to say it better "nice half game". I still wonder where all the money went. As another user said "They asked for $400,000 to make a complete game. They got $3,336,371 instead and only managed to make HALF a game with it. " and he forgot the money they made from the steam sales.


Update 10/12/2014
"The next half is coming out early next year."

Thats not the point. Mr Tim crowfound a game, get 8 times what he asked for (and more from sale since release) and delivered HALF game with the same feature of a low budget adventure game and the promise of the other HALF "soon".
Soon became one year later (maybe). The fact that his company started to create more games at the same time should make anyone wonder if the money from kickstar have gone in this game (a 5 hour (soon 10?) adventure with no more asset than a low budget 20hours adventure) or in others Mr Tim projects.
Do the word "ethics" still mean something to someone else out there?
What happend recently to another Mr Tim game (Spacebase DF-9) should be a clear evidence of what kind of business we are dealing with here.
But everyone is free to think different.
I'm still waiting for Mr. Tim giving us an insight on this project and how the money where spent, havent heard from him since he stated in an interview that "the second half of the game is founded thanks to the first part sales". Glad to ear that 3.3 milions wasn't enough for this masterpiece man.

Not worth the current price at all. Took me 2 hours to beat, the puzzles are non-existant and I only got half a game. When the other half comes out then maybe get it, but not right now.
Save your money and get something better.

Kickstarted this game. They asked for $400,000 to make a complete game. They got $3,336,371 instead and only managed to make HALF a game with it. The money is already gone. Double Fine used to be a name associated with fun, quirky, and experimental games but now it's becoming synonymous with bad project management.

The game itself is cute, has a nice visual style, but as far as point-and-click adventure games go it's almost too easy to really enjoy it. Sure, the hunting for a single pixel stuff from some of the old games in the genre was stupid, but this jumped into the other ditch at times.

I recommend the game if you're either totally in it for the story, OR if you're academically interested in the genre. It will be interesting to see where Broken Age lies in the history of adventure games and interactive storytelling.

But overall, the game itself is actually kind of hit and miss. I'd have to wait to see if the second half really ties it together before giving it a solid general recommendation.

The puzzles are...whatever. Nothing stood out as particularly clever or interesting. I think part of the problem was that problem space to work with was always so small that matching puzzles to their solutions was straightforward. It was very linear for an adventure game. The dual-story thing was an interesting idea, mechanically, because it lets the player progress along different lines if they're feeling stuck on something. However, that idea was kind of wasted on a game as "narrow" as this.

Speaking of the story, thumbs up. It's interesting and pretty unique, and maintains a feel of wonder and mystery, as you try to piece everything together. The dual-story contributed to that a lot. The world was filled with neat characters; by that I mean they weren't particularly likeable or memorable, but they were distinct and well conveyed. There's a lot in the world that I'm still curious about, but I feel like this is one of those things where if the payoff in the conclusion isn't good, it'll just spoil everything up to that point.

The game isn't funny. It's humorous, sure. The characters have a sense of humor, and there are jokes, and it doesn't take itself too seriously, but it's not a comedy, which is disappointing for a project funded on the dream of classic Tim Schafer adventure games.

The art is downright stunning. It's amazing how well the visuals, the animation, and the sound blend seamlessly into such a cohesive style.

3 Years since I kickstarted this game, no complete game. Near radio silence from the developers. No solid information on a release date. The "monthly" documentary from the kickstarter is reliably late weeks or even months late. There was a few funny parts in this game, but it seemed geared towards children. After this and the Space Base DF-9 fiasco I'll never purchase another DoubleFine product again.

Don't bother.
The biggest complaint everyone has about this is that you're buying half a game, but really it feels more like just a prologue. The four hours I have on record are two playthroughs. Sure, the art is nice, but not almost 4million dollars worth- which is how much kickstarter funding this game got BEFORE it was sold on steam. Maybe it will be worth playing when it's completed, but after waiting a year for the second half, I've just lost interest.

When I got this game, it was priced at $16.99 and I thought it would be a good deal. I was worried about getting a game that was going to be split into two parts, but with that sale and the great things I've heard about it, I decided to pick it up. Here are my thoughts:

Positives:
1. The Art Style- This is the one thing anyone who's played this game (loving it/hating it) can agree with. The backgrounds remind me of a beautiful painting with unique settings, esspecially the sky level and the characters give off a creative design that you'd probably see on an art Tumblr (hopefully you won't land yourself on the political side of Tumblr).
2. The Voice-Acting- If there's a trend I've been getting scared of, it would be big actors in animated films and video games. To make a long story short, there's a major difference between an actor and a voice actor; actors can interact with others and an environment to help potray their characters and they can get away with playing themselves in movies and shows (example: John Malkovich). Voice actors can sometimes interact with others, but usually they have to act by themselves with the added difficulty of not being able to interact with an environment. And the voice actors have to potray a character. They can play the same character or similiar characters (whatever fits their talents), but (for example) Troy Baker can't just play Troy Baker, unless the story (mainly fanfic) calls for it. What I'm getting at is that an actor can have trouble translating their style to acting into another style (example: Bruce Willis in Apocalypse), and it's even worse when it seems like they don't care and they're only doing it for the paycheck (example: Megan Fox in Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen [which she won an award for best performance by a human female, seriously]). But there are actors who can voice act and this game is a great example for that (see reincorporation). People like Elijah Wood and Jack Black pull a great performance for their characters and the rest of the cast are great as well. Okay, enough ranting, next point.
3. The Side Characters- If you're wondering about my thoughts on the main characters, I'll talk about them eventually. But I enjoyed the side characters, they're not three-dimensional characters, but they're charming none the less.
4. Music- It's peaceful and calm. Nothing worth buying the soundtrack, but it works in-game.

Overall, the presentation excels in visuals and sound. But there are postives, there are negatives. And the negatives are where things go wrong.

Negatives:
1. Predictable Story- I'm not going to spoil the story, so don't worry. My problem with the story is that it's predictable with little to mix it up. The moment a character appeared in the game, I knew exactly what was going to happen to the last detail, and I was right. I felt cheated out of a game that was trying to surprise me with twists. The twists could have been examined to bring up interesting ideas, but the next negative made it so that wasn't the case.
2. The "Split into Multiple Parts" Trope- Something that I've noticed in recent years in movies is the separtation of a hollywood blockbusters (particularly the finale of an overrated book series) into separtate movies. To me, this is only done to make more millions that the original was going to make and this game seems to be taking that idea for its advantage. The game doesn't have enough to split it into two parts, it feels like one whole game halved to make two games, which doesn't allow the game to fully develop its story, without playing both separtate games. And there's not that much in this one game.
3. Length- This game took me 4.5 hours to complete. 1.5 hours of that being completely lost, only to end realizing that the game lied to me. Seriously. I combined two items together, then I tried every combination, then I went out searching for an item that I met have missed, didn't find anything, then I checked a walkthrough to realize that the two items I used before is the right answer (and it didn't make any logical sense [Seriously, Ladder shoes?!]). I even hear the people completed the game in 2 hours, a game that cost $25, half of a game that cost $25. I feel ripped off.
4. Gamplay- Aside the part where I got lost, the gameplay is so basic and bland that completing a 4.5 hour game was made even more a challenge on the psyche and it doesn't help the character walks so slow. There are no extra puzzles, no riddles, just walking and finding items.
5. The Main Characters- As much as I praised the voice acting, even noting Elijah Wood's performance as the main character, I can describle the main characters in a short describation. Shay is the princess with an overbearing king (this time it's changed to a mother-figure) who wants more. Vella is the strong independent woman who don't need no man. That's it. Even at times, they can get annoying, esspecially Shay.

My Overall Thoughts:
Not only am I disappointed in this game, I'm down right pissed. This game left me with such a dirty taste in my mouth, that I can't play the second part of the game. Especially when it's sold separate. There are way better point-and-click games out there, ones that have a better story, better characters, and most of all cheaper. But if you are interested in the game, a word of advice; Do not buy this full price and wait until the second part comes out.

I give this game a 3/10.

I really would like to recommend this beautiful marvel, but there are so many problems attached to it.
Imagine the Mona Lisa but with only one half of the smile and everything else missing. There is just a sticky note saying "coming soon". You can clearly see, this note has dust on it.

Get this image? That's Broken Age for you. And "Broken" could not be more fitting.

[this review may change if episode 2 comes out, but I do not expect this to happen in 2015]

There's a lesson here - don't buy an episodic game, as you can't rely on the developers finishing it even though you invested time in playing the first part! Terrible way to treat your customers!

I love the art style, music, the mood.

However, the game is a bit on the easy side. The puzzles are very obvious and it's impossible to deny the fact that this game is not finished.

6/10 for providing an enjoyable evening.

Since I got it off a sale at 7 euros I'd say it was worth what I paid for it. Full price? No. At least not until they finish it.

Can't recommend this game until they add more content.

i just can't recommend this game, its too short, its too easy, and its been way to long since any information has come out about the second part. This game has such a pretty art style and amazing voice acting and well crafted storys. However, WHERE THE HELL IS THE REST OF THE GAME. If and when the second act comes out i will change the review to include the rest of the game. ALSO WHY ARE GAMES THESE DAYS BEING CUT UP AND FORCE FED TO US IN LITTLE FREAKEN PEACES STOP THIS ♥♥♥♥!

I wanted to like this game. But for the price, it was way too short. If your considering buying it, wait for the second act.

I was one of the game's backers. I was hoping for an adventure game on par with the Schafer's Lucasarts classics...
But was disappointed.

Don't buy this. It's just the first half of the game (which you can finish under 2 hours) and it doesn't look like the other half will ever come out so far. The store page also hides this fact as well.

I really like the way the game looks. But I find it incredibly boring. All these never ending dialogs, replays and terribly slow gameplay. I think I could've enjoyed the game if I was 12 years old, but now it seems too slow and boring for me. I thought I liked slow games that don't really need too many actions from the player, but this one is too slow even for me. Sorry.

When Double Fine went to Kickstarter, it constantly reminded us of the past great adventure games like Grim Fandango and Day of The Tentacle to get people (including me) to contribute. So why is the "final" product NOTHING like these games? The graphical style alone has divided people but the rest of the game feels nothing like the old Lucas Arts adventures - the comedy is lacking, the puzzle quality is lacking, the colourful characters are lacking, the wacky art style is lacking ... it's just ... dull. And to realize how much money they blew on making this game when other Kickstarter games like Tesla Effect did much MUCH more with far less money, it makes you wonder what on earth happened.

The free adventure game "Host Master" was a far better game than this and it didn't cost 3 million dollars to make. Not only is Broken Age proof that quality games are not made by a single "big" name but rather by talented teams, it's also proof that lots of funds can still leave you with only half a game with an indie feel and look that realistically barely even covers 10% of the amount they raised.

Basically: big thumbs down.

The story is incomplete, the puzzles are stupidly easy and not thought provoking. The developer has a history of not finishing products as with Brutal Legend, Space Base 9, etc.

Not at all worth the current price, go buy Deponia instead.