Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.
用户评测: 特别好评 (288 篇评测)
发行日期: 2014年9月29日


购买 Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments



"Rough around the edges, and with some bad puzzles, but this is an atmospheric detective adventure that actually lets you do some detecting."

最近更新 查看所有(11)



[HALLOWEEN SALES] 25% off Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments on Steam. Investigate your way through a handful of horrible murders for the greatest Halloween ever!

3 条评论 了解更多



His skills, your wits!

You will find bellow some reviews of Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments ordered by language:






His skills, your wits. Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, is now available on PS4, PS3, Xbox One, Xbox 360 and PC!

7 条评论 了解更多


“I have to believe Holmes would approve.”
8/10 – Polygon

“Thrilling detective-game ... even Moriaty would play it!”
85/100 – GameStar

“Hands down the best detective game I've ever played and one of the most enjoyable experiences of the 2014 gaming year so far.”
9,5/10 – Hooked Gamers

They reviewed Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments


Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.

Will you follow your moral compass, or will you apply the letter of the law?

The great freedom of action in Crimes & Punishments allows you to conduct your investigations in the manner you deem appropriate. Use the 14 extraordinary skills of detection for which Sherlock is famous, choose the avenues of enquiry you wish to pursue, interrogate your suspects and, from your deductions, name the guilty parties... you can even determine their fate! The ramifications are far-reaching, and your decisions will exert a real influence through your reputation or the surprising consequences that will arise where you least expect them…


    • Processor: AMD/INTEL DUAL-CORE 2.4 GHZ
    • Memory: 2048 MB RAM
    • DirectX: Version 9.0c
    • Hard Drive: 14 GB available space
    • Sound Card: DIRECTX 9 COMPATIBLE
25 人中有 23 人(92%)觉得这篇评测有价值
18.4 小时(记录在案的)
Watson: "Do you want to slit some more pigs throats?"
Holmes: "no."
Watson: "thank goodness for that."
Holmes: "I wish to impale one with a harpoon."
20 人中有 16 人(80%)觉得这篇评测有价值
9.7 小时(记录在案的)
I let two murderers go free and blew up the London Stock Exchange.

5 stars.
9 人中有 9 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
19.8 小时(记录在案的)
I wasn't expecting much from this game, but I have been consistently impressed by the quality of the writing, voice acting, and visuals.

Playing as Sherlock Holmes is made interesting by way of a unique system for connecting deducations (represented as synapses in his brain) that creates different outcomes depending on how they are arranged. You gain deductions by following up on clues, which requires talking to people, inspecting the environment, and playing a variety of mini games (everything from lock picking to arm wrestling, to chemistry).

The characters have incredibly good facial animation and well rendered skin (definitely the best use of sub surface scattering that i've seen in a game) which, combined with some truly stellar voice work, gives them an extremely 'human' quality. All of this leads you to care about them, and the stories they have. That's a pretty important thing, because the bulk of the game is spent listening to them speak.

If you are into adventure or puzzle games, or just someone who appreciates great visuals and attention to detail this is a game well worth picking up.

I would give this game 10/10 raging clues.
6 人中有 6 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
15.2 小时(记录在案的)
Vast improvement over the last one, Testament of Sherlock Holmes (which was itself a lot of fun).
-Graphics are way better (and you get to customize your appearance a little)
-Voice acting has improved slightly
-You won't spend time looking at completely irrelevant items
-The morality/decision making is fun (I also really liked how you can go back and change your decision and see all the different outcomes)
-You can replay separate cases after you've solved them
-There's still an overall ending (but you won't understand it unless you pay attention to dialogue from the beginning)

There were a few things I didn't like:
-Way too short, could have used more cases!
-You can't change your appearance very much besides specific situations, before you beat the game once
4 人中有 4 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
16.9 小时(记录在案的)
A good adventure game.

Pros: Very pretty, great VO and art. Nice puzzles nothing too taxing and interesting cases and characters

Cons: A lot more linear from previous games, the random cases were nice but there was no background story there to tie them together really.

A step back from The Testament of Sherlock Holmes but still a good game for those that like adventure games.

Enjoyed my time with it and it was quite meaty time wise.
4 人中有 4 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
27.2 小时(记录在案的)
What an amazing game! I think this is probably the best game I've played in over a year.

The graphics are very good, it's easy to manoeuvre in the game and even I as an amateur detective can solve and enjoy the cases, but I also made some mistakes, so the game isn't super easy -- yet anyone can play this, I'm sure!

What makes this game stand out and go from solid to phenomenal, is the stories. There's six stories (cases) in all. Great dialogue and the game leads you from step to step. It's fairly easy to find clues, but the smart part is that YOU, the player, get to interpret the clues.
To give you an example, you find clues that the rails are removed near a lake and near a cave. You're looking for a disappearing train. What do you deduce? You need further evidence to make the correct deduction. If you do this well and interpret the clues correctly, they will lead you to the correct conclusion. But if you make errors, you can reach a wrong conclusion and send an innocent man to prison or the noose! Brilliantly done!

You really feel you're back in Sherlock Holmes' day and age, with gas lamps and coaches. It is so well done, I even started reading a book with Sherlock Holmes stories after finishing this ~27-hour game. Turns out the stories in the game could VERY WELL HAVE BEEN WRITTEN DOWN in the form of a book. So this game plays great for Sherlock Holmes enthusiasts as well as for SH rookies. Big thumbs up!
4 人中有 4 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
16.2 小时(记录在案的)
Bought this a few days ago, massive massive fan of Sherlock Holmes and didn't even notice that this game was out until a few days ago. Bought it immediately and love it so far! Love the character portraits you do and the style in which you do them (similar to the Sherlock BBC series in terms of editing). The London Baths case took an eternity to do near the end but it was good being challenged. GREAT graphics and a 10/10 for me.
4 人中有 4 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
20.3 小时(记录在案的)
This is the first game ever to make me actually want to buy a DLC (Which I don't know exists).

The graphics are beautiful, and gameplay's great, if a little easy at times.
I really like the new deduction mechanic, and the new profiling mechanic.
The cases are interesting and varied, and feel like they naturally belong in a "Sherlock Holmes world".

Figuring out the conclusion of every case is very nice because it makes sure you don't just click around without actually understanding what's going on. Some of the cases are harder than others, sometimes the conclusion is pretty obvious and sometimes it's really hard to figure out, I got it wrong in one of the 6 cases. I like that the possible conclusions keep changing with new evidence.

Would have been more challenging if you had to pick which item to use when you need "an object of interest" instead of the game just giving you the right option. Also would have been more challenging if the game didn't tell you when to use the "Sherlock Talent" and the "Sherlock Imagination" abilities.

The environments are beautiful, would have loved to try this in VR. I spent some of the time just looking around and enjoying the scenery. Voice acting is very nice in my opinion; a historian friend of mine noted that Sherlock's accent didn't sound right, but I had no problem with it.

Overall a very fun experience for me, I enjoy games that make you think, and this is much better than just a regular adventure game. Would love to play many more cases, but the game is definitely worth buying "just" for those 6, every case is more than an hour of very interesting content.
6 人中有 5 人(83%)觉得这篇评测有价值
15.6 小时(记录在案的)
By far the best Sherlock Holmes game out there.
2 人中有 2 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
17.8 小时(记录在案的)

voice acting
sound work
visuals to an extent (Toby doesn't look quite right)
case stories
mini games
interesting real world facts in some cases
imagination mode

load times = long wait times for traveling
a lot of back and forth traveling, which wouldn't be so bad except for the load times
being forced to use the detection ability, even when some clues are pretty obvious
repetative use of the lock picking mini game

Mycroft is an annoying, egotistical, preachy, self entitled, judgemental, rude, butt.
On one case, my decision at the end was entirely influenced by my desire to say f-u to Mycroft.

I own the Sherlock Holmes collection and have played Nemesis, Jack the Ripper, and Testament so far. All of which I have enjoyed. I was really looking forward to Crimes and Punishments and immediately bought it once it was released.

I can happily say I do not regret this decision.

Another person commented that "the whole game plays like Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's 'The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes'" and with that I can agree. None of the cases are solidly connected with an over arching plot, but there are some slight connections and references here and there. Including some throwbacks to the older games.

The quick time events are actually well incorperated in my opinion, and come at relatively appropriate times. They really help to add to the feeling of using Sherlock's skills.

The cases are enjoyable and some have large deduction trees, which makes for an even more fun final conclusion. Sometimes you can gather enough clues and evidence to make an immediate deduction, but without all the evidence, there is a possibility that deduction might be wrong.

I think I would have enjoyed being able to play as Toby a little more. I also feel the disguise system was under utilized and somewhat limited in the promised freedom of choice.

Lastly, I agree with Watson. Fyodor Dostoyevsky's "Crime and Punishment" was a very hard book to understand. It took me almost 6 months to finish it and that was because near the end, I dreaded having to pick up the book.
Also, Mycroft is an ♥♥♥ and he insulted me personally with what he said to Watson about understanding the book.
2 人中有 2 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
16.8 小时(记录在案的)
No spoilers.

I want to start off by saying I liked the cases and the methods of solving the cases. They were individually fun and entertaining, some more complex than others.

What I want to discuss is how much I did not like the game as a whole. Having played other Sherlock games by this company, I expected a lot. Maybe too much. The cases did not build on each other. The ending was lackluster. I sat here for five minutes wondering if that was it and if I missed anything because all I could do is watch Sherlock smoke a cigarette.

Maybe I expected too much. I loved Testament and the ending. I finished that game feeling really good about it and even went to YouTube to rewatch the ending because it was great.

I don't know if they left it open ended on purpose, but it left me feeling like I worked towards nothing. It was a fun 17 hours of game play and any Sherlock fan should love it. But I expected more from this company.

PS: If you have a laptop, get a mouse or you won't be able to do any of the puzzles. Had to skip them all which made me mad because that was a lost achievement ...
2 人中有 2 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
14.3 小时(记录在案的)
Seems like a test for a new engine and a new game mechanics. Kind like "we'll try it out on C&P, and next time when we master it fully we'll give you something BIG!" I really have this impression after playing. Too easy, too smooth gameplay, too little of worthy puzzles inside. The only challange is to pick a lock. Like someone said: the game plays itself. But I am a fan of the series so I like it nevertheless.
2 人中有 2 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
17.9 小时(记录在案的)
This game is doing a great job at story telling. Every case feels unique and offers interesting and well-written dialogues and deduction phases. The character design and overall graphics are amazing. I really hope the creators will release a bunch of DLCs in the near future, so we can continue our investigations beyond the 10 hours of the original game in the Victorian London and the surrounding areas.
2 人中有 2 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
13.0 小时(记录在案的)
TL;DR: A strong recommendation. Might not be everyone's cup of tea, but especially for any Sherlock Holmes fan out there, this shouldn't be missed.

Longer one:

The best one in the series. Frogwares has really managed to capture the oldschool holmes vibe and once again did something a bit different to break their formula - something I respect a lot. The production values have also gone up a notch once again, as did the writing of the cases. I also really, REALLY liked the deduction space in this one and the possibility to do totally wrong deductions and even accuse the false party (something I also enjoyed a lot in for example LA Noire). This one wasn't that much about the puzzles, but really capturing the essence of Holmes. It's easy to see how much the team loves the title character (and I also bet the old BBC adaptation of the Holmes cases :) ).

The ONLY real nag from me is the hand holding nature of the "inspector-mode". Why on Earth have they decided to not put the hinting icon for switching into inspector-mode (and re-enactment also) as an OPTION, in beyond my understanding. IMO this game would've been even better, if that could've been turned off and let for the player to figure out when to use it.

Can't wait the next one in the series, as Frogwares have better themselves on every instalment.
2 人中有 2 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
20.0 小时(记录在案的)
Let's play a game, its called "How many ways can I say Awesome?"

First off, its hard to screw up great content. The Sherlock Holmes books have spawned tons of movies and tv shows and continues to maintain its fan base for a reason. Compelling and dynamic characters in head scratching situations.

So why have Sherlock Holmes games been so bad for so long? I don't know, because these guys figured it out.

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments has all the asthetic, visual, and sound effect excellence that Bioshock Infinite has. The experience in each moment makes you want to play more. Add in to that the freedom (such that it is) to explore and examine things AND the Moral choices left entirely to the player and this game is Stupendous, Spectacular, and A-Stounding.

I loved every moment, and I can not urge the developers enough to put out DLC.

Please, please, please, please.
2 人中有 2 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
12.9 小时(记录在案的)
An outstanding murder mystery adventure. I didn't expect a lot from a Sherlock Holmes game but it sure as heck blown all that doubt away. If you like games like L.A, Noire you wont find it here but you will find a very well made Sherlock Holmes adventure. Every case feels like something the late Sir Arthur Doyle would write which is an outstanding feet.

1 人中有 1 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
12.9 小时(记录在案的)
Overall, a great detective game. 10/10. Would prefer the addition of new cases ASAP. Personally this game convinced me to pursue a job in forensics.
1 人中有 1 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
12.3 小时(记录在案的)
I've played this game, and i'm really happy with how the game went on with the cases.

If you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes and Doyle's novels, you're going to love this game. The game is dazzling graphically. Gameplay is also polished, you will be taken through a detailed detective procedural. The voice acting is particularly good. Some of the most awesome cases from The Return of Sherlock Holmes are featured in the game.

The only thing that disappointed me a little was how Watson was used, i would he wasn't even much used. But still it's good to have him by your side while investigating a case.

It's an easy 8.5/10
1 人中有 1 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
16.7 小时(记录在案的)
Enjoying this a lot more than the first one. The story progresses along well enough that it's quite easy to watch someone else play the game without feeling too bored. Probably doesn't have a lot of replay value, but it remains fun enough.
1 人中有 1 人(100%)觉得这篇评测有价值
13.1 小时(记录在案的)
A truly captivating game. It's clear that a lot of hard work as put into every aspect of the game, as its difficult to even close out of the game. While requiring some smarts to solve various puzzles, it also supplies an interesting experience each playthrough, with multiple conclusions to each case and difficult moral decisions.