Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.
使用者評論:
最新:
極度好評 (65 篇評論) - 87% of the 65 user reviews in the last 30 days are positive.
整體:
極度好評 (1,345 篇評論) - 1,345 個使用者中有 93% 為該遊戲做出正面評論。
發售日: 2014 年 09 月 29 日

登入以新增此項目至您的願望清單、追隨或是標記為無興趣

購買 Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

 

評論

“I have to believe Holmes would approve.”
8/10 – Polygon

“Thrilling detective-game ... even Moriaty would play it!”
85/100 – GameStar

“Hands down the best detective game I've ever played and one of the most enjoyable experiences of the 2014 gaming year so far.”
9,5/10 – Hooked Gamers

They reviewed Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

關於此遊戲

Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.

Will you follow your moral compass, or will you apply the letter of the law?

The great freedom of action in Crimes & Punishments allows you to conduct your investigations in the manner you deem appropriate. Use the 14 extraordinary skills of detection for which Sherlock is famous, choose the avenues of enquiry you wish to pursue, interrogate your suspects and, from your deductions, name the guilty parties... you can even determine their fate! The ramifications are far-reaching, and your decisions will exert a real influence through your reputation or the surprising consequences that will arise where you least expect them…

系統需求

    最低:
    • 作業系統: WINDOWS VISTA SP2/WINDOWS 7/WINDOWS 8
    • 處理器: AMD/INTEL DUAL-CORE 2.4 GHZ
    • 記憶體: 2048 MB 記憶體
    • 圖像: 256 MB 100% DIRECTX 9 COMPATIBLE AMD RADEON HD 3850/NVIDIA GEFORCE 8600 GTS OR HIGHER
    • DirectX: 版本:9.0c
    • Storage: 14 GB 可用空間
    • 音效卡: DIRECTX 9 COMPATIBLE
    • Additional Notes: INTERNET CONNECTION REQUIRED FOR THE GAME ACTIVATION
Customer reviews
Customer Review system updated! Learn more
最新:
極度好評 (65 篇評論)
整體:
極度好評 (1,345 篇評論)
Recently Posted
mrwells
( 0.6 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 24 日
The gameplay is quite slow and very predictable. If you like obvious and forced game play, then this is the perfect game. The depth/rendering gave me an instant headache and a bit of nausea. I think I’ll have to go consider wasting money while trying not to vomit.
Helpful? 搞笑
Eugene
( 25.0 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 24 日
-On English-
It's a great game! But I have a few comments:
1.Very strong color saturation and high contrast in scenes.
2. Constant flashing of many textures (some parts of the objects are black, and some parts are normal), perhaps due to my graphics card AMD Radeon HD 7800 Series.
3. Poor quality of many textures. Tree textures, picture frames, furniture, most Kew Gardens textures are terrible! Often the texture of high quality and low quality are located next to each other. In the excavations in Saint Albans, some standing next to the each other textures differs in brightness.
The graphic style of this game reminded me of "No One Lives Forever 2". Textures need the "Bump Offset". The game needs pastel colors. The color palette of British homes and gardens are more complex and refined. It needs a subtle color harmony (here can help Adobe Kuler).
4. You do not need to prompt the player every time he need to press the "T" or "F". It's enough to make it one time in the beginning. The player must guess when he need to press the button. In such places enough to show a quite small glare on objects, flashing dots or Holmes might say "hmm ...". In any adventure game should be the "pixel hunting".
5. The game need "inventory" with items. The player must guess which of them need to be combined. There may be unexpected combinations, which are difficult to guess.
In any quest there must be the moments when you need to apply a certain item at a certain place in a one second. The player must catch the moment.
6. Dialogs are too simple. The player must choose the right words to make the suspect to cooperate. There should be a specific sequence of replicas.
Not many people with whom you can talk. It facilitates the process of investigation. It may be better to make more people with whom you can talk, but they should not help. The player must choose the right person from a crowd.
7. All cases in the game are too simple. Everywhere there are hints, clues and evidence. This is a job for an ordinary detective, but not for a Sherlock Holmes!

For example, a difficult case for Sherlock Holmes (!I saw this story in Russian movie!): naked body of the man was found in a closed inside an empty room in the apartment house. No evidence, no clues there. Sherlock and the police are confused! In an empty room there is nothing that could catch the trail of the killer. This room was not rented for a long time. How this man appeared there- it's a mystery! An autopsy showed that the man was not poisoned, not been shot. But he drank some coffee shortly before his death.
Sherlock is looking for cafes, in which he could drink coffee before death. There are many cafes around this place. After some time of searching, intuition tells Sherlock to pay attention to a man who differ from the crowd of people in this quarter, in one of the cafes. Suspicious man drinking coffee in the cafe and looks like a scientist. Sherlock decided to follow him. The waiter in the cafe does not know anything about this person. In pursuit of this scientist Sherlock gradually learns that the victim had taken a wife of this scientist. The scientist was professor of psychiatry, an experienced hypnotist. The wife of the scientist was in love with the victim.
When the doctor found out about it, he called opponent on a conversation in an outdoor cafe, where they together, drank coffee and arguing who gets the beloved woman. The doctor hypnotized his opponent and tells him about a hired killer. Doctor said, that a killer is chasing this man! Killer knows how the victim looks like. In addition, the doctor persuaded the poor guy to hide himself from the people and lock in the room, otherwise he will be in extreme danger!
The poor fellow was so frightened that he quietly stole the key from a room in the nearest apartment house, locked himself in this room, undressed and threw the clothes in the window where it was successfully stolen. A few days after lying on the floor with a wild sense of fear, despair, hunger and thirst, the man died. A few days later the body was found.

Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson investigates a case of mafia cartels. On the way from the crime scene to the Scotland Yard the cab flips and breaks up. Holmes and Watson knocked out by three murderers. When Sherlock waked up, he saw a huge pit from which it is difficult to get out. Watson tied to a chair and waiting for interrogating from a strange man, trying to find out what they know about a crime scene, where they have been earlier. Finally have not ascertained anything from Watson, the man goes to the window to see where Holmes are. During this short time Watson should find on the table an acid or something sharp to cut the rope. When the offender is moving away from the window and fills a syringe with some substance, Watson unties the rope. The man brings syringe to Watson, and Watson knocks the syringe from the hand of criminal. Then he strikes a bottle on the man's head and knocks him out. In this case, player need to quickly perform actions, cleverly hide from offenders and maybe even shoot.

In addition, the game needs a mission on the London Eye or Tower Bridge.

The game needs a mission with encrypted letters or inscriptions on the wall.
Helpful? 搞笑
quockerwodger
( 28.0 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 22 日
This game forces you to make moral decisions that may go against your moral code. It makes you truly feel for the characters through a deep and well crafted storyline.

10/10
Helpful? 搞笑
Shelley
( 29.1 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 22 日
This is without a doubt the best Sherlock Holmes game I have played (and I've played all of them). The puzzles are amazing, difficult but not impossible. The fact that you have to consider all of the information you've been told as well as the clues you have found, and incorporate it into an overall conclusion is true to Holmes' original character from the Canon. Then the moral choices make the game unique in the franchise.

I really hope they go back to this format for the next game (after The Devil's Daughter I mean) as it is definitely better than the format for the Devil's Daulghter.
Helpful? 搞笑
sevter
( 19.0 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 14 日
Recommended...with reservations. SH:C&P is a great casual detective game. However, it's a terrible Sherlock Holmes game.

THE BAD FIRST
As a major Holmes fan (of both the original books and the new series), I was terribly disappointed by the out-of-character portrayal of Holmes and by the lack of true detective work that you need to do in this game. Clues are practically spoon fed to you on every case and the conclusion can be terribly obvious for certain cases, not requiring much brainwork. Not much world-building as you are confined to certain sets and there's not much character-building as well - they're all fairly cookie-cutter.

THE GOOD
Don't play this as a Sherlock Holmes game. Play this as a casual detective game with Sherlockian elements and you won't be disappointed. Kudos for good attempts at building atmosphere and decent storylines (with great voice acting). The series of mini-games in multiple cases keeps you from becoming bored and allows you to break the game in parts without losing your place in it. You do have to use *some* effort to reach the correct conclusion for all six cases, though it's not up to Sherlock Holmes standard. Looking back at the end of the game, after I tempered my expectations, I did actually enjoy the gameplay a lot.

[Bought during Steam Summer Sale for $15]
Helpful? 搞笑
palex00
( 18.7 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 11 日
Cannot recommend this game for the price of 30 bucks. The murder stories are just.. a slight grips. There is no red line going through the whole game. Plus it's just a game written on the base of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's novels so I cannot see why the price is so high: The script is already there. I would have wished a game where there original murder cases that would also allow a little bit... more deepness. Like... I didn't "care" for anyone. I didn't know their stories - well a little bit but not... you know what I mean.

So ya.. I bought it for 15 bucks in the summer sale - still not recommendeble. Get it for 10 or don't get it at all.
Helpful? 搞笑
Viki
( 11.2 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 9 日
After playing both this game and Devils Daughter, I am certain this one is better.
Helpful? 搞笑
mmmth
( 14.3 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 7 日
Perhaps the best installment in the Sherlock Holmes series. Great dialogue, great stories. The challenge is putting all the pieces together, browsing back dialogue. Sometimes it takes time to understand it all, but sometimes everything is too obvious (for a fan of murder mysteries anyway). The puzzles are not challenging at all, on the other hand.

I feel like the game aids the player a bit too much at times: like telling you when to use the super sight and do the re-enactments. Combining clues is rather forgiving, and results often in just smashing through to the right choice. I also felt that the Blood Bath had many red herrings, and none of the choices seemed right - it's the only case where I replayed my initial selection. I might've just missed something, so I'll probably re-do it soon.
Helpful? 搞笑
The King in the North
( 17.1 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 6 日
Nice gameplay. Beautiful surroundings. Fantastic story.
Helpful? 搞笑
Truculent
( 0.4 記錄時數 )
張貼於:07 月 3 日
Really bad port.
Helpful? 搞笑
Most Helpful Reviews  In the past 30 days
7 人之中有 7 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 2 位使用者認為這則評論很有趣
推薦
15.0 記錄時數
張貼於:06 月 25 日
畫面不錯,細節也高,尤其是房間與窗外的街景,可惜本作為案件線性遊戲,不能隨意看風景。角色的對話對嘴也很好不違和,面部表情細節不錯,案件有許多推論的分支,不會玩來玩去都是一個結果。 推薦
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
7 人之中有 6 人(86%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 2 位使用者認為這則評論很有趣
推薦
16.4 記錄時數
張貼於:06 月 28 日
Growing up reading Sherlock Holmes mysteries made it hard for me to like any other adapted media version of the character. But Crimes and Punishments stole my heart! The atmosphere and gameplay perfectly reflects the classic Doyle atmosphere.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
3 人之中有 3 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
推薦
14.6 記錄時數
張貼於:07 月 2 日
After a good long while of meaning to play this game, I finally got around to it - and it did not disappoint. First off, the gameplay elements.

Crimes and Punishments is my second Sherlock Holmes game by Frogware and it is a vast improvement on The Awakened. Splitting the game up into six self contained cases rather than one big case was a brilliant idea - you can complete each case in a few hours play, say an evening. This makes the game easy to pick up and drop as you feel like playing as there is no requirement to remember all the previous hours of game play. Your case book is also a lot better organised and is easy to use, indicating where you need to further investigate a clue. The deductions screen is also very cool, and there are no penalties for making a wrong choice at this stage which is useful for when things get a bit ambiguous (The railway and roman bath cases spring to mind!)

Playing in 3rd person, while allowing you to get a good look at the entire scene, makes it a bit more difficult to pinpoint those 'clues'. I played the first 2 cases entirely in 3rd person and switched to 1st in the 3rd case. I found it a lot easier to spot things in 1st person.

Annoyingly, sometimes you must find or deduce things in the 'correct order' before the game will allow you to continue. I suppose this comes down to the fact that as the player we can see things we might need (by nature of the fact we're playing a mystery game and know we'll need to work around problems) before Sherlock himself realises he needs them. This isn't too much of a problem, if not slightly irritating at first. Just try to think like you're really in the situation, not playing a game.

I only found one of the cases (Kew Gardens, the 5th case) to be a tedious, though it's ending was by far one of the more interesting ones so it gained back some brownie points for that.

This game suffers slightly from the mistake of Awakened where Sherlock often makes medical assumptions/observations when Watson is right there - as someone who dislikes the 'bumbling idiot' portrayal of Watson this wound me up when it happened but it didn't impact much on my experience except for passing annoyance.

On the hardware side, the game has ages okay. The graphics hold up fairly well, the controls are a little clunky but fine once you get used to them. I'm not sure why, but I experienced lag throughout the game when I have a machine capable of running current (2016) AAA titles. I experienced the same problem with The Awakened which is even older so maybe it's steam's ports or Frogware's engine but something to keep in mind if the occassional jitter is something that would bother you.

All in all, I'd give this game a solid 7/10 in today's market. Enjoyable, and definitely worth the price if you can get it on sale like I did. Good for a few evenings entertainment and has replay value in solving each case with the alternate ending to what you picked the first time.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
3 人之中有 3 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
推薦
12.7 記錄時數
張貼於:06 月 30 日
Finally the Sherlock Holmes game that we deserved. Collect all clues, decide who the culrpit is, and take the moral decision of absolving or condemning the culprit (that's entirely up to you). Be warned though that you may choose the wrong culprit and the game won't stop you from taking the wrong decision. This game is really good and you should buy it.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
2 人之中有 2 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
推薦
5.4 記錄時數
張貼於:06 月 30 日
'Elementary'

And not a modern reboot-style game. They stay true to Arthur Conan Doyle's characters and gives us a game of wonderful suspense and immersion. You will lose yourself in Sherlocks world, and sit on the edge of your seat as you work the cases with your "superhuman" detective skills.

A deduct system enables you to keep track of and connect the different clues you discover in a case, and can be combined to create different theories about who the culprit might be.

Really interesting gameplay with a great feel to it.

The good old Eccentric Sherlock - Skeptical Watson chemistry is also very present.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
1 人之中有 1 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
推薦
13.5 記錄時數
張貼於:06 月 29 日
They really need to remove all these silly minigames and add something of value instead. And I do hope they've cut down on loading times between the scenes in the sequel. Otherwise, it's a good Holmes game, if you've ready to forgive a couple of inconsistencies in the evidence, like "The cylinder recorded by Miss White appears to be quite lengthy, thereby proving that she remained in her laboratory on the day of the crime." in the Kew Gardens case..
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
1 人之中有 1 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
推薦
19.0 記錄時數
張貼於:07 月 14 日
Recommended...with reservations. SH:C&P is a great casual detective game. However, it's a terrible Sherlock Holmes game.

THE BAD FIRST
As a major Holmes fan (of both the original books and the new series), I was terribly disappointed by the out-of-character portrayal of Holmes and by the lack of true detective work that you need to do in this game. Clues are practically spoon fed to you on every case and the conclusion can be terribly obvious for certain cases, not requiring much brainwork. Not much world-building as you are confined to certain sets and there's not much character-building as well - they're all fairly cookie-cutter.

THE GOOD
Don't play this as a Sherlock Holmes game. Play this as a casual detective game with Sherlockian elements and you won't be disappointed. Kudos for good attempts at building atmosphere and decent storylines (with great voice acting). The series of mini-games in multiple cases keeps you from becoming bored and allows you to break the game in parts without losing your place in it. You do have to use *some* effort to reach the correct conclusion for all six cases, though it's not up to Sherlock Holmes standard. Looking back at the end of the game, after I tempered my expectations, I did actually enjoy the gameplay a lot.

[Bought during Steam Summer Sale for $15]
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
2 人之中有 1 人(50%)認為這篇評論值得參考
推薦
14.3 記錄時數
張貼於:07 月 7 日
Perhaps the best installment in the Sherlock Holmes series. Great dialogue, great stories. The challenge is putting all the pieces together, browsing back dialogue. Sometimes it takes time to understand it all, but sometimes everything is too obvious (for a fan of murder mysteries anyway). The puzzles are not challenging at all, on the other hand.

I feel like the game aids the player a bit too much at times: like telling you when to use the super sight and do the re-enactments. Combining clues is rather forgiving, and results often in just smashing through to the right choice. I also felt that the Blood Bath had many red herrings, and none of the choices seemed right - it's the only case where I replayed my initial selection. I might've just missed something, so I'll probably re-do it soon.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
Most Helpful Reviews  Overall
19 人之中有 19 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 2 位使用者認為這則評論很有趣
推薦
22.4 記錄時數
張貼於:2015 年 08 月 24 日
福爾摩斯,我對他其實並不太熟,
過去的接觸點只有過電影、和動畫中提到的片段而已。

初接觸本作是在江小M的遊戲實況中,
當時就認定這真是一款有深度、又有趣的作品。

當發現英特衛出了中文版,真是超開心啊!!
綁 STEAM帳號、比原價便宜、有中文、又有成就系統,非常超值啊!!


遊戲中,跟隨著大偵探的步調查案,
在頻繁的場景切換中找尋蛛絲馬跡,
需要經過發現、查證、模擬實驗、演繹推理、組合... etc.

不斷的思考和判斷,在緊湊的劇情下,
一投入真讓人想接著看下去XD!
案子平均耗費3小時腦力,就像真的在看福爾摩斯電影一樣,感覺非常充實啊 !!


和大家分享幾個有趣的點:
1. 跟緊緊的夥伴
  很多時候,場景搭上詭譎的音樂,其氛圍非常令人發毛。
  如果這種時候,有人「突然出現」是非常過份的,
  我常常一個轉頭就被華生嚇個半死...

2. 不同的角色扮演
  視場景或劇情需要,有機會扮演其他角色。比方:偵探犬的視角。


優點的部分:
1. 豐富的人物感情:人物焦慮的汗水、各種情感的肢體語言都很真實。
2. 多重結局:根據判斷和道德的抉擇,讓故事有著許多變化。
3. 結案前上一動:若想看其他結論,可在抉擇後回頭重新做演繹推斷,就不用再重頭跑一遍了!!
4. 精美又有深度的畫面:許多運鏡、和造景都很迷人!!


個人遊戲耗時紀錄:(用Steam累積時數計算)
第一關 3 小時 、第二關 3小時、第三關 3.1小時
第四關 1.8小時、第五關 2小時、第六關 2.5小時
最後為了成就狂個性,額外 7小時左右,重頭到尾快速衝刺 XD


在本作中認識的大偵探福爾摩斯,真覺得他超帥的啊XD
如果這時重新去認識他的電影,應當會有不一樣的發現!


這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑
2 人之中有 2 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
推薦
12.5 記錄時數
張貼於:2015 年 11 月 16 日
如果對於福爾摩斯這個人or解謎遊戲有興趣的話,強烈建議要買!最著要的是可以體會福爾摩斯的演譯法!
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 搞笑