Making History - The Great War: Write your own story and change the course of history as you lead of one of the Great Powers during the era of the First World War. Can you prevail as modern industrialized warfare changes the age of empires forever?
使用者評論: 極度好評 (100 篇評論)
發售日: 2015 年 01 月 29 日

登入好來將此遊戲加入您的願望清單或是標記為無興趣

購買 The Great War

包含此遊戲的合集

購買 Making History: The World Wars

包含 2 個項目: Making History II: The War of the World, Making History: The Great War

 

由多名鑑賞家所推薦

"Released from Early Access, good alternative to Paradox/other Grand Strat games. Some-what dated UI/Graphics but very indepth detail & scale."

最近更新 檢視全部(51)

04 月 27 日

Making History: The Great War is now $29.99!

We've had such a great response from our sale that we have decided to permanently lower the price of TGW to $29.99!

Making History: The World Wars is an even better deal, both TGW and MHII for $34.99.

Making History II by itself has been lowered to $14.99.

1 則回應 繼續閱讀

04 月 27 日

Making History: The Great War Updated!

This weeks release is focused on Editor and Workshop improvements. We will continue to develop these features to facilitate TGW Modding.

Here's the list:

Game/Editor:
- Fixed bug that allowed players to cancel unit orders for other nations
- Renamed Production to Projects in summary panel
- Added new Project icon in Summary panel
- Modders can now add new units again for a unit group in the editor
- Modders can no longer create a group without units in the editor

Lobby/Launcher:
- Fix for mod names not showing up in different locales
- Several UI fixes for editor page
- Small Art pass on Upload Screen
- Changed Button Label: "Upload" to "Upload To Steam"
- Fixed editor footer button alignment on Mac OS X
- Fixed steam version not finding Steam license key
- Enabled Steam Workshop for Mac OS X
- Fixed bug that would keep Mac mods from being uploaded to Steam
- Fixed bug that would automatically append Mac mod names with a '.'

2 則回應 繼續閱讀

評論

“Muzzy Lane has definitely developed a real winner here with Making History: The Great War”
RTS Guru

“Making History: The Great War is a game you have to try out if you’re a fan of the genre or not”
Softpedia

“Making History: The Great War is an exceptional title. It automatically will appeal to those gamers who know what they’re doing, as well as those willing/able to put the time in to learn.”
Just Press Start

What to expect from the most recent update:

    For this update we wanted to focus on enhancing player accessibility with better in-game feedback, greater AI activity, and most importantly, integration of Steam Workshop for The Great War. We are looking forward to working with players to create an active and creative modding community. The Editor is fully functional. We’ll be addressing usability issues and adding more features in the coming months. As always, we’re interested in hearing from you on what’s working well and ideas on tools to facilitate the process.

    There are more improvements to naval gameplay that should present new challenges to the Great Powers. The AI now has Anti-Submarine initiative. Enemy destroyers will try to hunt down and engage your Submarines fleets. This is a counter to the Wolfpack tactics we added in the last update. Naval AI will consider fleeing losing battles and seek out a safe port where they can repair and refuel ships. Additionally, we’ve modified the decision making around declaring Unrestricted Submarine Warfare since sinking non-combatant trading vessels can ruin relations and trigger war.

    In the UI we’ve continued with our efforts to develop the Summary Panel into a centralized location to monitor critical game updates. This is an area we feel has potential to evolve and offer customization so players can choose what’s important to them. Another improvement that we intend to build on is incorporating some AI decision making into the notifications. The game will now give a reason why a nation went to war.

    And finally, the tech requirement for making Gas Shell technology has been relocated to an earlier spot on the Research Tree. As a result, expect to see more green haze on the the battlefields.

A complete list of Release Notes can be found here:
http://steamcommunity.com/games/279140/announcements/detail/239031128722316754

關於此遊戲

Making History - The Great War: Write your own story and change the course of history as you lead of one of the Great Powers during the era of the First World War. Can you prevail as modern industrialized warfare changes the age of empires forever?

Your actions will influence world events as you navigate a path through shifting alliances, emerging technologies and self-serving nations who hold power over vast populations eager for war. Control industrial expansion, engage in trade, create alliances and lead your military forces in one of the most detailed WWI grand strategy games ever made.

GET THE FREE DEMO NOW. Click the DOWNLOAD DEMO button above.



  • Change the course of history: Begin at historical starting points then make your own decisions.
  • No two games are the same: Each of the great power nations has a unique character and situation that will require different strategies to succeed.
  • Experience an entire world going on around you: React to hundreds of possible historical world events from assassinations to the sinking of the Lusitania.
  • Immerse yourself in the historical era: Hundreds of nation specific ground, air and naval units as well as city architecture that reflects the time period and geographic location.
  • Mobilize your nation for war: Try to achieve victory before your treasury -- and your manpower -- are wiped out.
  • Control the Seas: Use your naval fleets to own the seas and blockade ports, or wage unrestricted submarine warfare and sink ships trading with your enemies.
  • Make strategic government choices: Establish colonies and puppet states to create buffer zones, win new allies or avoid rebellions.
  • Buy and sell in a global economy: Trade resources and manufactured goods on the world market or directly with other nations.
  • Build and improve transportation to grow your empire: Use rail to connect regions to increase trade, resource extraction, industrial expansion and troop movement.
  • Expand your sphere of influence: Use foreign aid to increase ties with other nations.
  • Use the “play anytime” cloud-based multiplayer service: Effortlessly play huge multiplayer games by taking your turn when you wish, even once a day. Role-play your historical counterpart in the diplomacy forum at the http://making-history.com website.
  • Make History: Create and share your very own customized “What if…” historical scenario with our detailed scenario editor.

系統需求

Windows
Mac OS X
SteamOS + Linux
    Minimum:
    • OS: Windows 8 / Windows 7 / Windows Vista / Windows XP with Service Pack 2
    • Processor: Pentium 4 or better
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: 256 MB DirectX 9.0c-Compliant, Shader 2.0 3D Video Card
    • DirectX: Version 9.0c
    • Hard Drive: 2 GB available space
    • Additional Notes: Windows-Compliant Keyboard & Mouse
    Minimum:
    • OS: OS X 10.6 Snow Leopard or later
    • Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo (PowerPC not supported)
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Hard Drive: 1 GB available space
    Minimum:
    • OS: Ubuntu 12.04 or later
    • Processor: Intel Core2 Duo 2.4Ghz or Higher / AMD 3Ghz or Higher
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Hard Drive: 1 GB available space
值得參考的用戶評論
91 人之中有 74 人(81%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
29.0 記錄時數
張貼於:01 月 29 日
A very... VERY detailed Geo-political simulator with a plethora of unit models, playable countries, and modability.
However, the UI is rather out of date and it is definitely a time sink. At first can be incredibly overwhelming, but the ability to completely control the economic and military power of your chosen country is hard to resist.

I'm about to spend a lot of time making my own history out of the Russian Empire >:)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZRJysP7xZo
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
106 人之中有 81 人(76%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
22.5 記錄時數
張貼於:03 月 2 日
Started off playing as USA and invaded Mexico taking their territorys and citys set up a blockade around puerto rico and then the allies alliance declared war on me I put up a good fight but forgot about the damn Canadians.
So after all this I joined the axis alliance and then russia declared war on me.Game Over
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
329 人之中有 221 人(67%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
36.7 記錄時數
張貼於:2014 年 11 月 23 日
I removed my previous review and I am completely refreshing this review. This is mainly to the Developers of MuzzyLane (( forgot your name sorry :/ )

I know you guys have been anxoiusly waiting for me to change me review to recommended. You have worked very hard to try to fix the problems & flaws in the game, and I recognize & respect that. But I am just voicing my honest opinions on The Great War and why I cannot change it to reccomended

Let's start with the less-major problems. It still lags when you move the map around. I recroded the frames, I get (with a limiter) 30 Solid frames, without 300-400 Frames whilst the camera is not moving. When I drag it around, it drops to 5-7 Frames. That gets really annoying. The turns still take a really long time to end. What I mean by this, is the time for the AI To process their turn. Not to process my own. It takes on average 34-36 Seconds early-mid game. Once you get later it bumps up severly. Same with the FPS On moving the map view/camera aroud. Later the game the more lag. The AI still isn't very militant at all. Other than WWI, I haven't much wars. A few rebellions being coiled here & there. But actual war-wise, nothing. Also, the AI seems to not like to build very large armies. I was on turn 100, as France. I had a huge army ready to fight Germany (WWI Was dodged, and I was preparing to declare war on Germany) They had at best 30-40 Units. And they were Militia and Infantry I. I had Marines, Inf II, and the whole 9 Yards. Almost to Tanks.

Not for the bigger problems. What really drive me away personally

The main problem for me is how long the fighting takes. I know you've tried to fix it, I recognize and, again, respect that. But it still isn't fixed. Little scraps against Bulgaria still take 10-15 Turns. On one land tile. Not to mention if I were fighting a large nation, like Russia, or the US. It takes forever. I understand you want to keep the realistic WWI Trench-Deadlock simulation going, but it, (for me atleast) ruins the game. I know that War isn't the only aspect, but it's my favorite, and my main aspect of any strategy game. I like feeling like the Emperor that created the (enter nationality name here) empire, and took on the masses and took over half the world in a matter of so and so days or months or years, w/e. You get the point. And the turns taking awhile, I know I mentioned it in the lesser problems, but it is still a big problem for me. If it takes 30-40 Seconds (On average for mid-late game) To end turn, imagine a battle that lasted 10 turns. That. Would. Be. Torture.

Anyway, I'm really sorry to not give you the rating you have been waiting for. I really don't like saying no you to guys, cause you're good guys and good developers, who are just trying to please everyone, I get that. And again, I'm sorry. But I just can't reccomend it. Yet.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOvkUDnRDhE < Video on my main probem
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
187 人之中有 130 人(70%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
16.8 記錄時數
張貼於:02 月 12 日
I recently posted a negative review of this game because the CD key didn't work - or so I thought. The company's tech support worked with me and determined that the fault was indeed mine, not the game's. I am hereby retracting my negative review and posting a positive one, with a public apology.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
36 人之中有 32 人(89%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
88.2 記錄時數
張貼於:03 月 23 日
Making History II: The Great War is a grand strategy game set around the time of World War I (there are two starting scenarios, one starting in 1912 and another starting before the assassination at Sarajevo in 1914 going into the 1920s and the Soviet Revolution) This game consists of the entire world cut into small regions, accurately representing the borders and geography of all countries that existed at the time of your chosen scenario, with various populations, cities, and resources in each region. In this game (it is a turn based strategy game with each turn taking 1 week) you can choose any country in the entire world and lead that country, industrializing it, modernizing it, engaging in diplomacy with other countries, waging war, facing crisis such as rebellion, invasions, and famine. This game also implements an event system with some events that follow actual history such as the building of the Panama Canal, and others that will be triggered by drastically changing history such as the unification of Scandinavia or the resurrection of the Byzantine Empire. Another interesting thing is that at any time in the game you can save your game and then resume it playing as another country (even countries that didn't exist at the beginning of the scenario you are playing) Another thing that this game possesses is an internal editor that can be used to change many aspects of the game, from creating new countries to changing the values of regions such as nationality or religion. Using the editor you can create amazing new scenarios of alternate history that you can then play and publish to the main website. After about 70 hours of this game I can definitely recommend it,
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
32 人之中有 27 人(84%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
105.8 記錄時數
張貼於:03 月 20 日
If you are a fan of Paradox Games, Imperial Glory, other Geo Political games such as Super Power 2 you will enjoy this game. The game can be a little overwhelming at first, There is a bit of a learning curve but can easily be learned even with out the tutorial if you have played similar games.

I love the amount of depth this game has, Although war is a major focus point it is far from being the only point. One thing i dislike in similar games is a vast amount of waiting around with nothing to do. This game has plenty to manage while you are waiting for troops to build. If i had to compare this game to another game Supreme Ruler comes to mind as far as what you can do micromanaging wise. As much as i love the Supreme Ruler series this is in my opinion a superior game for the sole reason that i find this game more of a joy to play.

If you are looking for a strictly historical game you may be a little off put as the game is guided towards world war 1 events however it is only a suggestion, I have yet to play a game that was the same, There were times that world war one happened without a hitch and i was fighting off Germans in Belgium, Other times I became the cause of a World War due to my military expansion of Romania. There were times that other conflicts would prevent world war one but start other conflicts around the globe such as Colonial territories rebelling against their owners. The randomness of this game can be a blast.

The game also comes with an Editor that anyone can use, This means that if you want to build a world war two scenario you can, Do you want to recreate the Roman Empire you can, Whatever your imagination can come up with. These scenarios can also be uploaded on the Making History website for all to download.

The Developers are extremely active and listen to the community, I have never experienced the amount of help that is given by the developers to the players than in this game. They have made it clear that this game will continue to be a major focus with continued updates and added features for the foreseeable future.

If you are looking for a game in which you will keep telling yourself one more turn and you realize that was the 30th time you said that then here is the game. Would highly recommend.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
30 人之中有 25 人(83%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
58.5 記錄時數
張貼於:04 月 3 日
The short TLDR version: it's a great, strategy 'world game' with high production values, great MP play and covers the period perfectly. It's what RISK would be like if a group of Professors and history buffs modded the hell out of it and pumped it full of steroids. In fact, that's not far from the truth. Muzzy Lane are without doubt *the* academic game developers with an undeniable academic and gaming pedigree for historic sandbox strategy gaming. Their line-up includes MIT grads, noted world-famous academics and some of the best coders and designers around.
This is a well-researched, very well-constructed strategy game for thinking people and warlords alike.
While it's possible to go-for-broke and unleash the dogs of war from the start, you can also roleplay your nation historically (or ahistorically) and fulfil your desire for world domination, domination of a sphere, or run your empire or nation benevolently and attempt to prosper and grow. The game covers economic, scientific, diplomatic and military areas with detail and puts the controls of your nation at your fingertips.
Each power has it's own sphere of influence, and if you start becoming involved in areas of the globe in which they hold an interest, then you will be warned and war might even follow. It's a game where you cannot just bludgeon through without facing consequences. Armies must be supplied and also fed. Food plays a vital role (which is not covered in other games of Grand Strategy) and transport of that food is vital if you ship it from abroad. This is where control of vital areas comes into play, and also trade warfare such as unrestricted submarine warfare. You really have to think strategically in broad strokes to achieve your goals.
Also, the technology of the warfare of this period is unlike anything you may have been familiar with before. Warfare is in a new era that renders the old Victorian style of warfare (which didn't change much from Napoleonic times) obsolete. The machine gun changed all of this, making wars long, costly and with terrible attrition. A nation has it's War Weariness measured in the game, which affects the nation's will to fight. You can wrestle it out on long fronts, hoping for a breakthrough or you can try to end the deadlock by pouring troops into your meat-grinder and waging a war of attrition. Technology plays a vital role in gaining an edge, as new weapons and methods of waging war, like gas attacks, better artillery, assault troops and aircraft can turn the tide of battles. Eventually, one side will break and they will gain that extra territory. You need to make sure it's you.

There is also a wealth of demographic map overlays to satisfy the most obsessive map fiends. They cover amongst other things, religion, ethnicity, trade, infrastructure and so on. It's also worth noting that the economic and trade parts of the game are highly enjoyable and you can make a lot of money or gain precious resources this way. The market also reacts dynamically to supply and demand, so, you can do things like buy a lot of one resource on the market to drive the price up, and vice-versa. If you have the added privilege of owning major sources of that resource, then you can effectively destabilise other nation's economies without firing a shot.

The UI is typical for Muzzy Lane: uncluttered, easy to process, easy on the eye and with ease of access to all info in a very sleek and classy-looking way. You can go deep into the sub-menus for all kinds of interesting and vital info. The in-game encyclopedia is thankfully in-game and not online. This contains all info on unit stats, buildings, and everything else you would want to know. The manual also has extensive info on this and it's not a two-page leaflet with install instructions, a screenshot and key commands. It's a proper manual.

Finally, if you really want to create new scenarios, the editor will allow you to do this. You can recreate anything from the turn of the century to the inter-war period of the 1920's and early 1930's.
This period is very ripe for all kinds of alt-history scenarios and with bit of research you could make something really cool.
Or, you can cheat and give your nation a huge army, air force and navy, all available tech and then steamroller across the world if you like.
You can share the scenarios online through Muzzy Lane's website.


If you play global strategy games, then this is a game you must own.

I'll give it 9/10, one point off perfect, because I want to see them make a WW2 game like this.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
31 人之中有 24 人(77%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
47.4 記錄時數
張貼於:01 月 8 日
搶先體驗的評論
This turn based strategy game takes on a very authentic early 20th century Europe.

Assume direct control of any country before the first world war, command its military, navy and air force.
The nation descriptions are accurate and give you a general idea of the situation that befalls you in the scenario that you choose.

Combat is simply moving grouped units through territories adding in factors such as trenches, artillery, terrain. It is done simply, but with stacked units. Battles can take weeks in game.

Armies have accurate sprites with superb uniforms/skins for each distinct nation, they can be moved by land via your nations veichle or the faster railway/railcart stockpile, or by sea via transport capacity.

Rescources like Arms, Fuel, Coal, Metal, Food, are nessecary for the survival of your Nations war machine.
Fund rebel insurgents or political factions in rival nations to ensue disorder and public unrest to the point of armed rebellion and even civil war.

Similar to the time, Alliances are made and broken easily. However do not expect Allies help if their borders are far from your own until they develop the technology/resources to send military intervention. (IE USA helping GB & France)

I recommend this game to anyone who enjoys the Making History series. Or anyone who is interested in first world war era.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
22 人之中有 18 人(82%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
126.2 記錄時數
張貼於:01 月 31 日
The devs have done a lot to this game since beta, the release version is a very good game. A bit like Paradox's grand strategy games like Victoria 2 this strategy game is however tightly focused on the Great War, so you have observation planes, trenches, observation balloons, bombardment artillery, airships and even gas attacks.

It's got a lovely simple GUI, which for a game like this is very important. You need to be able to control all your production etc in one place. This game does that really well - one screen set to control production of factories, infrastructure and resources - its really easy.

Messages are well presented with popup screens and clear notification icons, you are given opportunities to make grand changes from these popups as well like when playing as the Austro Hungarian Empire you can choose to ask Serbia for harsh terms or go easy on them. Interesting diplomacy options then, but there could be more choices like being able to raise bad relationships or insult other countries, which would just add a bit more gameplay into the diplomacy.

Graphics wise lovely looking clean map, sprites all have authentic uniforms. Externally applied anti-aliasing works well here to improve the whole look of the game (but it should be made configurable from within the game I think) - BUT choose enhance game settings for AA in the Nvidea Control Panel, not override game settings, which seems to blur the text in the game for me.

You can trade for food and other resources that you need which is good, its taken me two years of gametime but my economy is now pretty sound in the game - it is a struggle when you start a new game getting your production and resources working well. But dealing with that stuff is more fun than it sounds and it all works well.

The AI is quite passable - it tends to attack pretty well and goes after badly defended provinces, it keeps you on your toes - I am presently fighting on four fronts! But it doesnt seem to protect its high value provinces very well - I walked straight into the Ottoman's Constantinople without a fight. There are some other AI bugs like countries taking trade agrrements then cancelling them again next turn. But they are relatively minor. Combat seems to go on for ages and it should be lengthy where trenches are utilised, but perhaps should be made a bit quicker for small skirmishes in open ground. I know this is being looked at by the devs at the moment trenches are a bit to easy to build so battles drag on too much.

Turn generation for me has been very fast i am up to 1915 after 130 hours in my game and the generation is no different to when I started - takes at most ten seconds which seems very fast to me.

I am playing AustroHungary and wouldnt even think of playing such a large country in Paradox's Victoria II but in this game its dead easy. I really got the game though to be able to play Great Britain which has so many colonies that in more complex games it looked a nightmare. In this game though I think it will be possible.

My present epic game as AustriaHungary has me fighting quite a historical war although Russia is starting its civil war in 1915 (thank goodness) and Italy is proving to be rather stubborn to fight on when it has no chance of taking my mountainous provinces. So enjoyable watching how these sorts of things pan out, watching the Chinese Communists fight against the Nationalists, and watching small countires like Bulgaria, Greece and Montenegro banded together against me (not that it made much difference in the end).

Overall is a nice simple looking, but deceptively complex, game that is more immediate and less faff to play than Paradox's offerings. It is only going to get better over time as the devs tinker with it - and they are very dedicated to make their game as good as possiboe which is very nice to see. We even have underline mining and AI anti-submarine attacks in the game now.

So yeah I like it, nice to see a good WW1 game at last and this is certainly the best WW1 game out there by far. I now play this and Elite Dangerous and thats pretty much it!
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
28 人之中有 19 人(68%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 3 位使用者認為這則評論很有趣
11.8 記錄時數
張貼於:2014 年 11 月 16 日
-Recommended Title-

MH:GTW, is a a fairly easy gs (grand strategy) title to get into. The graphics are fine, they have a dated look - which is great, because the look, fits the period.

The gameplay is easy to get into, and you can get immersed immediately into carving out your own history - indeed, making history.

More content is being continually added, with an additional scenario's having been included recently.

The dev's are engaging with the community with regular updates, and are very active on the forums, and on other social media platforms.

It's a different style to typical gs titles, to play - and I like that. But I still feel like I have control of most areas of my "Empire" . I have played as New Zealand, and attempted to conquer the world. I did get Australia to cede to NZ's greatness - which was pretty satisfying :P

At the end of the day, it depends on how passionate you are about period gs games and adopting early access in spending your dollars. But I think, participating in helping to get a Great War gs title released, just adds to the experience, which I enjoy :) As an RTM release, definately worth the money and a gret addition to the Making History series, and GS titles in your library.

The game is scalable , you can sit back and cruise as a smaller nation ( low ranked) or get "amongst the thick of it" as one of the top 15 nations .

Bear in mind, I've only played 5 hours so far, but I like what I see in the early access version.

There will be a tutorial included in the release. the current game manual, is quite extensive - and is being added to, continuously. **Update** Tutorial is now included, and is based on the start of WW1 with the Austro-Hungarian nation as the subject of the tutorial.

There have been reports of crashes with the game by other ea adopters. To date, I have not experienced any. Performance does need to be tweaked though, espc. during the AI moves. Otherwise the game runs fine on a Windows 8.1 laptop

Early Access Score: 8.75/10
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
41 人之中有 26 人(63%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
66.8 記錄時數
張貼於:03 月 31 日
I really want to likie this game. It has a very high level of economic detail. It is a micro-manager's paradise. The learning curve is sharp, and the game doesn't seem to try very hard to help you. There are a bazillion messages popping up on the screen after every turn, and you just cant read them all. They tell you trivial things, like unit recruitment, but not that your towns are not developing and such.

The real snag is the gameplay. This is such an old school interface that it seriously interferes with gameplay. You are constantly merging and reforming armies... armies that you can't even drag a box around!

Then the fighting... well it certainly captures the charnel house effect of the great war, but what it doesnt do, is readily identify the size of enemy forces roaming around. Some are a unit or two, and others are hundreds... this should be very obvious on the map. As for balance, it seems messy. France is easily defeated in Europe. Conversely, Russia feels conspicuously powerful.

But after a a healthy 40 hours of gameplay I have to conclude it is a bit lacking. Hopefully future patches will address some of these things.

3/5
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
18 人之中有 13 人(72%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
8.1 記錄時數
張貼於:02 月 1 日
Fun game, if your familiar with grand strategy games it should be easy to pick up and play. The one of the best WW1 gs ive played but theres not many out there. The only big issue I have with game(and the series) is that there is no repercussions for going to war (i.e USA can take over all of Central Amercia and South Amercia without any internetational intervention) they seemed to try to fix that for this game but it doesnt really work to well. The only other kinda big issue is the UI looks alittle wanky at the start. Overall if your into grand strategy/a history nerd like me id say buy it, but if your not you can pass on this one.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
10 人之中有 7 人(70%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
60.1 記錄時數
張貼於:02 月 3 日
This game is definitely better than previous Making history 2 and 1.

+++++
They added many things which I personaly missed in previous games like improved trading system which is pretty cool and improved government interface.
Propably the best improvement is that you are no more dependent on how many factories you have in each city like in previous games and you can build, produce and recruit at the same time which is also very cool.
Also you dont have to build new mines, you just expand it and prospect.
Also there is much more life in a game like some events and many wars without you starting them :)
Another thing is the fact that you cannot just simply occupy every small country next to you, becouse the other countries would crash you...
I find this game very challenging, becouse you will have difficoulties to get more resources to improve economy.

-----
One thing I propably dislike are the reactions of other countries when you fight another country. I started as a Spain and invaded Portugal. After I took their provinces and started taking their colonies, every country next to the province a just took started to mobilize and one by one started declaring war on me... seriously? Some time later Britain, France, Belgium, and their allies were at war with me... and i only wanted to invade Portugal... realy frustrating

To sum up it is a great improvement in compare to previous Making history. Many things I disliked in previous games are gone. I realy enjoy playing it. Maybe the price could be a little cheaper... But I would definitely reccomand you this game.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
3 人之中有 3 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
25.8 記錄時數
張貼於:04 月 28 日
The learning curve is a bit steep, however once you understand the mechanics of the game, it's really awesome. I liked the fact that it's not as complicated as Paradox's. I also like the fact that you can play as any nation. Trading simulation works really well. Interface is very clear and to the point, free of "decorations" (which I really dislike in other titles). For the ones who would like to get into this game, I strongly suggest doing the tutorial, reading steam discussion boards and watching you tube videos by CommisarBRO (that's what made me buy this game) to get some valuable information. What I would like to see improve is diplomacy. I've noticed that it's very hard to improve relations with other nations. Often they will refuse help if you're trying to send some, and there aren't really much other options. This is a first turn based grand startegy for me that I got into (I didn't have patience for HOI or EUIV which seemed overly complicated and I had no clue what I was doing even after watching extensive tutorials). Cheers
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
7 人之中有 5 人(71%)認為這篇評論值得參考
35.3 記錄時數
張貼於:01 月 25 日
搶先體驗的評論
Making History: The Great War is a fantastic edition to the Making History series. With tons of new options to allow a whole new gameplay experience, this game is the working itself out to be the best Making History yet - as well as one of my new favorite games. However, it should be dutifully noted that this game is still in a playable Beta stage. Most of the parks are working and mesh well together, but there are still some bugs and kinks to work out before the final version is released.

To be fair, the game will probably continue to be updated throughout the period of it's lifespan due to the forum community and the amount of time the Developers spend there. Unlike some larger game companies, Muzzy Lane actually takes its time to listen to their customers, their fanbase, and does their best to implement suggestions that are made by the community. Personally, I have paid tribute to several suggestions that I have made being directly implemented into the game, quite often within the next two updates (which are fairly frequent for such a small staff).

Needless to say, I believe this is the game that we all hoped Making History II would/should have been. Thankfully, Muzzy Lane is rather quick to realize what works and, quite often, what does not. A fresh UI that reflects the era, a more expanded diplomatic system, and even a brand new "claim" system should all help project The Great War into the top spot for 20th Century Strategy Games.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
17 人之中有 10 人(59%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
202.1 記錄時數
張貼於:04 月 1 日
positives:

1. fairly simple in design but complex also.

2. tooltips are very handy as well as the encyclopida

3. each unit type has its own sprite, at least that I have seen and its not rinse and repeat...

4. TBS, not for RTS players, allows for more things to happen at once.

5. trade is well thought out and implemented(minuses coming in the negatives ;D)

6. economy is well thought out and balanced to a degree


Negatives(not many of them):

1. wish that there was more items to sell than arms, road capacity, rail capacity, ship capacity, food(generic), metals(generic), oil, fuel(generic), etc...

2. wish there were more units and more factory types/crop types/farm types

3. Wish there was more than one type of "product" that could be made as a primary and secondary products... IE like a steel mill... they made two different types of steel. One would be similar to wrought iron and the other would be hardened steel. for example that is.

4. population regain needs twecked or something... its rather sad that you only get .003 mpu back per a turn. for anything worth while.

Anyhow, those are my thoughts at this time...
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
2 人之中有 2 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
48.7 記錄時數
張貼於:05 月 2 日
I've played MH series games more then other game series. TGW is no different and i highly recommend it to any armchair general worth his salt. Muzzy Lane the relatively small and unknown studio behind this series is fantastic for customer support (i've exchanged direct emails with the developer team reporting bugs, they explained in great detail why these bugs existed and how they would fix them) They are professional and love the subject matter with a deep passion. The updates never cease as well, adding additional fixes and content with each new update. The forums are filled with passionate and friendly people dying to discuss history and tactics, overall a very welcoming and friendly community. Modding support is built into the foundations and this shows with the map Editor which gives you the ability to rework the game entirely as you see fit, with the built in option to upload mods you create directly to the steam workshop or to the making history website. Multiplayer is also available and is incredibly addicting to play with friends. This game truly makes you feel like YOU are making the history.

I recommend this game at a STRONG 11/10 for those wanting a serious and rewarding world war 1 RTS unlike anyother in terms of playability and satisfaction.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
1 人之中有 1 人(100%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
233.8 記錄時數
張貼於:02 月 3 日
Good game. Really fun to play.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
3 人之中有 2 人(67%)認為這篇評論值得參考
27.8 記錄時數
張貼於:04 月 20 日
Another great title from the Making History series.

MHTGW has a lot of improvements over the previous installment (MH2):

- nation growth more balanced;
- better (and harsh) insurrection and revolt system;
- artillery really bombarding the enemy units;
- better micro-management;
- great unit detail and diversity, based on nationality;
- better looking map;
- detailed research about the (over-underestimated) WWI era;
- amazing community and run-by-community multiplayer matches.

The Making History series is of the same style of Iron Hearts, but easier to manage and the players' actions have a bigger impact in the game.

Warning: this is a game that will suck hours and hours of your life. And it will worth it.
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣
4 人之中有 2 人(50%)認為這篇評論值得參考
有 1 位使用者對這則評論感到有趣
19.6 記錄時數
張貼於:01 月 27 日
搶先體驗的評論
Making History: The Great War (TGW) is a deeply modified game in the series of Making History of whom I already had the previous two.
The idea is to go back in time, dress as one of those leaders and guide your nation through difficult times with the possibility to make different choices vs history.

The game has a level of depth that is complex enogh for making it interesting but not so much detailed that is like true life taking out fun.

One very interesting addendum to the game is the online gaming where a great community organized strategic playing (one turn per day) with 30-40 players per game with a gaming interaction but also a diplomatic side in the forum. Very compelling.

I fully reccommend this game as the previous one called MH II where we still play a lot online.

One good attitude of the publisher Muzzy Lane is to continue development and fixing years after the first release. That is real value and why I'm here making a review. They earned it.

Buy it, take some practice against the computer and then get online for your strategy master with us :-)
這篇評論值得參考嗎? 有趣