Recenze

“Whether you're playing alone, online or couch head-to-head, SMB 2 is simply fun. You're not overwhelmed with overly complex mechanics, but also not dumbed down so far that you aren't challenged. From a gameplay standpoint, it lives in its sweet spot.”
8.6/10 – Forbes

“The follow-up keeps the accessible hitting and pitching mechanics, smooths over some rough edges, and adds everything that was missing, including multiple online modes, a detailed team editor, and custom leagues. Basically, it does everything a sequel should do, and the result is the best on-field baseball sim on PC.”
88/100 – PC Gamer

“New players can expect a solid game of baseball with enough arcade magic to appeal to almost any type of player. Baseball purists will find a good time if they enter with the proper expectations. As it stands right now, Super Mega Baseball 2 is now the top dog of baseball games on the PC.”
8/10 – Shack News