Hardest no I've ever written. I love the games in the party pack. They're a lot of fun. My family and I have managed to get a few hours of entertainment out of them and I have immensely enjoyed the content. You Don't Know Jack 2015 and Fibbage both feature Cookie Masterson, which is really the most important thing to know, with Drawful being the surprise hit of the pack.
You Don't Know Jack is a classic trivia game show environment where each question is posed, then each player is able to give their answers. Cookie is condescending and evil towards the folks who get it wrong, something that often provides a great spot of humor.
Fibbage XL is a fill-in-the-blank trivia game where each player gets to enter an answer, right or wrong, and then those answers are shuffled in with the real answer, at which point each player gets a chance to guess. Points are awarded to players who get the question right, and to the players who are able to "trick" the others into guessing. There are a few problems with Fibbage, mostly relating to the use of the language.
Fibbage's "true" answer can easily get lost in the mix. For example, say the answer to a question is "Grand Canyon" and you type in "the Grand Canyon" and your friend misses a letter and types in "Gran Canyon." You now have three VERY similar answers, with two of them being functionally correct, and the game won't detect it as being the same as the "correct" answer. This is both the source of fun in Fibbage, and a source of frustration.
Lie Swatter is a pseudo-trivia game where players must either answer True or False to the statements given. Some of the "lies" are remarkably difficult to spot, and players will enjoy trying to guess them.
Drawful requires players to attempt to draw things from the given category, and then other players will try to guess what has been... done. After guesses are made, players must determine the true name of the category. Like Fibbage, Drawful suffers from answer ambiguity in that adding articles or making typing errors can render the true answer indistinguishable from the fakes, but c'est la vie.
Word Spud, the low point of the pack, is a word association game played by taking random turns adding to the words given previously. So a 5 turn word order may look like this: Banana Split Decision Election Politics. Points are awarded by players voting on whether the given words were acceptable, so basically the points don't matter.
The games scored as individual games:
YDKJ - 9/10
Lie Swatter - 9/10
Drawful - 10/10
Fibbage - 9/10
Word Spud - 6/10
So why No?
Pseudo-technical issues. This game doesn't have actual local multiplayer support. Internet connection is a MUST, so no taking this game to a party center unless they've got wi-fi. The game requires that you sign each player into Jackbox.TV - admittedly not that difficult since you can do it from desktops, laptops, cell phones, tablets, toasters, etc. and use your "room code" to start the game. However! This connection to the online service
does not give you actual online multiplayer, either.
Players have to be able to see the host's screen in order to see the questions, the answers, and hear the awesome Mr. Masterson and streaming services have a significant enough delay to where YDKJ players would have a significant host advantage... sometimes by more than 10 seconds.
It gets hairy in practice, though - the people playing the game have to be comfortable with their individual devices, or one of you has to be technically inclined enough to be able to make sure everyone's devices are operating as expected for the entirety of the game. So if you've got a friend or relative or partygoer who doesn't have a cell, they're not playing, making this the least casual-friendly party game to date.
This leads me to my next problem - while I understand the need for the screen for Drawful, Fibbage, and Word Spud, I can't figure out why YDKJ and Lie Swatter aren't controller compatible. I should be able to hand each player an Xbox 360 controller (or use my Big Button controllers) which require LITERALLY no technical experience to use and put each player on an even playing field.
Xbox 360 controller support is only for playing You Don't Know Jack in single-player mode.That's ultimately my biggest problem with the system as it stands at release - in practice, the game is literally unfair. My parents are in their fifties and my mother's an amputee. We can't really play on an even playing field because my ability with the phone doesn't match theirs.
So, if you're going to get a group of friends together and they're all on equal footing in the smartphone world, then fine - this is a great game. If you're going to include anyone else... nope. Nope nope nope.