Anna - Extended Edition has been given an overhaul based on the feedback of the thousands of players of the original Anna.
사용자 평가:
Recent:
매우 긍정적 (평가 14 개) - 85% of the 14 user reviews in the last 30 days are positive.
Overall:
복합적 (평가 1,139 개) - 이 게임에 대한 사용자 평가 1,139개 중 66% 가 긍정적입니다.
출시 날짜: 2013년 4월 12일

로그인하셔서 게임을 찜 목록에 추가하거나, 팔로우하거나, 관심 없음으로 표시하세요.

Anna - Extended Edition 구매

 

평가

“You can be sure of this: Anna is an engaging horror tale, intimate and with a strong personality. The best possibile debut for Dreampainters.”
8.0 – http://multiplayer.it/recensioni/105996-anna-legami-di-sangue.html

“If you want to learn Anna’s secrets, you’ll just have to meet her in the sawmill yourself.”
9.0 – http://leviathyn.com/blog/review/anna/

게임에 대해

Set in an abandoned sawmill nestled high in the Italian mountains, Anna challenges the player to uncover horrific clues and use them to solve puzzles related to your character’s dark past. The player’s behavior does not only determine the mental health of the main character but can also change locations and unveil new secrets leading to one of eight possible endings.

Anna - Extended Edition has been given an overhaul based on the feedback of the thousands of players of the original Anna. It features more environments, more hours of game play, more puzzles, additional gameplay features, enhanced graphics and an improved interface. Anna – Extended Edition is sure to please fans of psychological horror games and offer an even more chilling gameplay experience with these new additions.

Features of Anna - Extended Edition

  • A haunting tale of psychological terror
  • Game reacts to player's actions, changes locations and starts supernatural events
  • Physics-based environmental puzzles
  • Eight possible endings, each determined by the player’s action
  • New environments, puzzles, interface and music
  • Improved Graphics
  • Creepy in-game character: “The Wife Doll,” with new AI

Extras included

  • Photos of the real-world sawmill location
  • Complete soundtrack (Songs will be placed in your Anna folder in the Steam Directory: ...Steam\steamapps\common\Anna\Extras\Soundtrack)
  • Main character’s notebook in English and Italian

시스템 요구 사항

Windows
Mac OS X
SteamOS + Linux
    Minimum:
    • OS: Windows XP
    • Processor: Dual Core
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: Shader model 3 graphic card
    • DirectX®: 9.0c
    • Hard Drive: 850 MB HD space
    • Sound: Stereo sound card
    Recommended:
    • OS: Windows 7
    • Processor: Quad Core
    • Memory: 4 GB RAM
    • Graphics: Nvidia series 3/4/5 or ATI HD series
    • DirectX®: 9.0c
    • Hard Drive: 850 MB HD space
    • Sound: 5.1/7.1 sound card
    Minimum:
    • OS: OSX 10.8.2
    • Processor: iMac Intel i5 2.7 GHz
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: Radeon HD 6770M 512 MB
    Minimum:
    • OS: Ubuntu 12.10.x
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Hard Disk Space: 3 GB
    • Additional: 32 bit systems only
Customer reviews
Customer Review system updated! Learn more
Recent:
매우 긍정적 (평가 14 개)
Overall:
복합적 (평가 1,139 개)
Recently Posted
Grim Gravy
( 4.9 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 25일
Time to beat: under 5 hours
Played with keyboard and mouse. Easy to control.
Bugs: none that i encountered.
Story: meh.
Motionsickness factor: I felt sick to some degree. Probably from the entire game being enclosed in a small house. :X

Fear: the game was creepy. Ambient sounds were alright. No jump scares at all, just things suddenly there that weren't there before...which at times took me by surprise. This is NOT an Amnesia-type game. It's not even action. It's more narrative.

This game has MULTIPLE endings. I only did 2. So with 8 different possible endings, I suppose this game might have replay value. I do not feel compelled to complete all 8.
I needed to consult a walk through on several occasions. Some things just aren't very clear on how to proceed with the tasks. (example, the 'Intuition' icons at the top of the inventory screen, I had NO IDEA what they were for. I thought they were chapter markers.) I suppose if I took the time to read all the 'documents' and 'books' in the game, perhaps there would have been some indication or hint on the tasks, but the fonts used were bloody awful to read, sooooo nope.

SO...would I recommend this game? I think I would say yes, but maaaaybe get it on sale and DON'T expect this game to be full of action and screams. It's really just slow paced and head-scratching.
Chex Lemeneux
( 9.3 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 18일
As someone who owned this game before extended edition, the first release had bugs but it was more simple and easy to finish.

Personally what I love most about this game is the music (Really nice soundtrack) and the art is pretty amazing as well.

I do admit puzzles are pretty "Wtf am I doing" or "Maybe if I keep clicking something will happen" but overall it's not that bad of a game.

7/10.
Mr Kitty
( 2.8 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 16일
stay away from this game, bad from start to bottom.
Everything from graphics, to gameplay, to complexity and immersion, this feels like some highschool kids created a project, and i'm not joking here.
A waste of your time and money. you want an interesting unique game go buy "Firewatch".
Slim Buddha
( 15.7 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 12일
Anna is an adventure with many horror and puzzles aspects. I would recommend the game to anyone with a willingness to enjoy an atmospheric game and not a gore-fest. Top on my horror/thriller list.
Observer (2)
( 4.0 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 12일
A weird but interesting story filled with many puzzles that have to be completed in order to continue. There is also more than one ending which can leave you wondering what happened exactly.

5/10
tehnoobpowns
( 1.5 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 8일
poorly optimised and crashes often.
omgtabby
( 1.7 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 6일
Weird visuals and cult like accoutrements are only the visual trappings of a horror game. Anna fails to deliver an actual horror game experience with the lack of any imminent threat to the player and relies solely on atmosphere that quickly loses its charm when you try to complete nonsensical puzzles.
Random Spark
( 35.3 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 4일
This is a slow, short puzzler. You walk, you click, you experience the mystery.

There are chilling effects, a few jump scares and lots of foreshadowing.

I can beat this game in less than 20 minutes because I am a speed runner.


Fans of Myst should pick up this title to have a little fun, the Devs are working on a "sequel" as of now.



The bad: some puzzles can be a little hard to follow, and not every thing is given to you as a hint. there is a lot of alchemy involved here.

The inventory can be misleading.

The readables can be misleading once they have passed their prime purpose.

Right click a lot.
Danamite
( 18.4 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 1일
Creepy, pretty, but a bit short. Aside from a few small bugs, this game works very well.
DooM
( 12.7 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 4월 30일
:D
goc9000
( 9.8 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 4월 28일
This was awesome. Very well done, genuinely scary at times, enthralling all throughout. The only downsides are that it crashes on Mac (so play it on Windows only), and it's not easy to figure out on your own what causes you to lose health.
trentonvitro
( 0.6 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 4월 17일
♥♥♥♥ this game.
James
( 0.1 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 4월 11일
Dislike horror 4/15
Ann
( 7.0 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 4월 2일
I really liked the random supernatural events and the creepy wooden lady appearing out of nowhere, however the ending was a bit dissapointing - the game ended quickly (took me 7 hours in total) and I just expected more from the story.
long life #f1sk
( 0.9 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 3월 24일
crazy adventure game logic that makes no sense. also jumpscares. very below par.
berzha101
( 2.9 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 3월 20일
Anna - Extended Edition was one of the earlier games that I got on steam due to it being in a Humble Bundle years ago before I started to collect steam games. Due to the earliness of me getting the game, I am writing this review years after I played it. However, I do remember quite a bit about this game and my hours played do not include the offline hours which would total to around 2 or 3 or 4 more.

At the time, I remember that Anna had some decently nice looking graphics and okay movement (at least on the outside of the house). However, the game was quite annoying in finding out what to do next as it didn't really give me lots of hints as to where and what. I also did not like the item usage controls but that wasn't too important. As I figured out what to do in Anna and started to progress through the story (which wasn't too straightfoward at all), I never really felt the scare which I expected that I might feel. Sure some parts were dark and creepy, but Anna never allowed me to feel the scare that games like Dead Space did.

Overall, if you enjoy progressing through a story and playing through some creepy situations, go with Anna. However, unless it is on sale, I would not recommend this game.

Rating: 6.4/10
Recommend: on 75% sale or better only
Ruby Bliels
( 4.4 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 3월 8일
Three separate play attempts, three separate walkthroughs followed to the letter, one game destroying glitch each time. I cannot possibly recommend a game that won't let me finish it because an important event towards the end cannot be triggered due to some unfathomable glitch.

And the 3rd Party DRM? What fresh hell is this? Steam itself is a DRM Slavemaster, but at least it works, I don't need temperamental 3rd Party DRM working in tandem that only lets you play your legally purchased game if it feels like it. I'd consider overlooking that point if the game actually worked, but it doesn't, so I won't.
jasminflower69
( 4.6 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 3월 3일
Is fun, but omg ended out spending half of the time wandering in circles.
It's a good game if you don't mind giving up and looking for walkthroughs because "Omg how was I supposed to find that?!"

Good graphics, good atmosphere, a couple of good jumpscares, and they normally don't scare me!
One Man and his Droid
( 1.5 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 2월 28일
...well presented, well designed, great soundtrack and haunting storyline... all the right elements for a great adventure game... my only criticism is that the puzzles are incredibly convoluted and it's sometimes really difficult to identify what to do / where to look at / what is even clickable... it does lead to a lot of trial and error... still, worthy of your time!
Rolepole
( 18.7 시간 기록 )
게시 일시: 2016년 2월 24일
That's the last time I will buy a game with "mixed" reviews. The main problems are:
1/ The clunky menus. This is evident even when you start the game. It takes about 16 mouse clicks to get going EACH TIME, which shows the designers simply have no concept of the player experience. Game play is largely ruined by constantly having to deselect inventory items, click through unnecessary text which blocks all other mouse actions, and closing the inventory by typing "i" instead of escape, all clicks requiring a little delay before the next action will work.

2/ I didn't find the pixel hunting too bad, but there is far too much randomly trying things in the inventory as some of the "solutions" are counter-intuitive. I am a seasoned adventure game player and like to play without walkthroughs but this just isn't worth the effort of doing so.

The game isn't bad looking but the "atmospheric sounds" feel like they just threw in random effects for a bonus. That's really the problem, it just doesn't feel genuine, it's too formulaic. The real giveaway is the trite writing in the diary, which reads like a schoolkid exercise. Give it a miss.
Most Helpful Reviews  In the past 30 days
2명 중 2명(100%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
4.0 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 5월 12일
A weird but interesting story filled with many puzzles that have to be completed in order to continue. There is also more than one ending which can leave you wondering what happened exactly.

5/10
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
Most Helpful Reviews  In the past 90 days
10명 중 10명(100%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
4.4 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 3월 8일
Three separate play attempts, three separate walkthroughs followed to the letter, one game destroying glitch each time. I cannot possibly recommend a game that won't let me finish it because an important event towards the end cannot be triggered due to some unfathomable glitch.

And the 3rd Party DRM? What fresh hell is this? Steam itself is a DRM Slavemaster, but at least it works, I don't need temperamental 3rd Party DRM working in tandem that only lets you play your legally purchased game if it feels like it. I'd consider overlooking that point if the game actually worked, but it doesn't, so I won't.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
3명 중 3명(100%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
1명이 이 평가가 재미있다고 함
비추천
2.9 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 3월 20일
Anna - Extended Edition was one of the earlier games that I got on steam due to it being in a Humble Bundle years ago before I started to collect steam games. Due to the earliness of me getting the game, I am writing this review years after I played it. However, I do remember quite a bit about this game and my hours played do not include the offline hours which would total to around 2 or 3 or 4 more.

At the time, I remember that Anna had some decently nice looking graphics and okay movement (at least on the outside of the house). However, the game was quite annoying in finding out what to do next as it didn't really give me lots of hints as to where and what. I also did not like the item usage controls but that wasn't too important. As I figured out what to do in Anna and started to progress through the story (which wasn't too straightfoward at all), I never really felt the scare which I expected that I might feel. Sure some parts were dark and creepy, but Anna never allowed me to feel the scare that games like Dead Space did.

Overall, if you enjoy progressing through a story and playing through some creepy situations, go with Anna. However, unless it is on sale, I would not recommend this game.

Rating: 6.4/10
Recommend: on 75% sale or better only
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
2명 중 2명(100%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
1.5 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 2월 28일
...well presented, well designed, great soundtrack and haunting storyline... all the right elements for a great adventure game... my only criticism is that the puzzles are incredibly convoluted and it's sometimes really difficult to identify what to do / where to look at / what is even clickable... it does lead to a lot of trial and error... still, worthy of your time!
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
Most Helpful Reviews  In the past 180 days
1명 중 1명(100%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
5.6 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 2월 15일
어드벤쳐 형식의 미스터리 공포 게임입니다.

실종된 아내인 안나를 찾기 위해서 주인공은 이름 모를 집에 자신도 모르게 이끌려 들어가게 되는데 그 안에서 벌어지는 일들을 그리고 있습니다.

여기저기서 아이템을 얻고 조합해서 적절한 곳에 사용하는 형식으로 게임이 진행되는데 게임 처음 시작부터 막혀서 공략을 봤다가 중간중간 계속 막혀서 결국은 공략 끼고 엔딩을 봤는데 해야하는 목적도 없고 아이템 조합과 사용도 단서가 거의 없다고 봐도 될정도로 불친절하더군요.

인터페이스도 상당히 불편해서 시종일관 짜증이 났네요.

상당히 불편한 점이 개선된 EE를 플레이했는데도 이정도인데 오리지날은 얼마나 불편한건지...

하지만 게임의 분위기와 스토리가 상당합니다. 갑툭튀가 상당히 많아서 깜짝깜짝 놀란게 한두번이 아니네요.

스토리는 영어를 대충대충 읽긴 했지만 상당히 좋더군요. 반전도 충격이었구요.

엔딩을 다 보고나니 공포영화 한편을 본듯한 기분이었습니다.

하지만 단점이 너무도 많기에 별로 다시 플레이해보고 싶지는 않네요.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
36명 중 34명(94%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
15.1 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 1월 24일
Game unusable and Refund Refused, stay away from this developer! After Three Years I have finally had enough of the intrusive (and highly glitchy) Registration Process every time I want to play this game. I really liked this game but I have never before come across a publisher who deliberately shoots themselves in the foot to this degree by barring the customers from playing a game they paid good money for. STEAM should do something about this highly suspicious (and creepy) company who are harvesting personal information and ripping people off in this way.

EDIT......

I had an important question about my review that I should share with the steam community. There is no doubt that Kalypso are selling our personal information to third parties. I got so exhausted from the glitching and inconvinience of the registration system that I created an email for no other reason than to use it for the registration process and nothing else. Sure enough withing days of doing this i started getting spammed from all sorts of buisineses and scams. The only people who ever had this particular email was Kalypso so they must be selling our personal information to third parties. It should also be noted that I left that particular email fallow for a month before registering it with Kalypso to see if It would get spammed if I did nothing, It didn't. That was evidence enough for me so I quickly closed it down. I made my findings known and took exeption at what they were doing, I asked Kalypso for a refund which they refused.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
16명 중 13명(81%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
0.3 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 1월 5일
When I first got this in 2013, my laptop could not handle it. I got a new PC recently, so I wanted to try to run it again. The game demanded I get an account on their website, which was annoying. What was worse is that the game claimed the product key couldn't be used again, so I can't even open the game. Be wary of this game.
EDIT: I tried to get a refund and was denied. Went to their website, and there is nothing about this game on it. I guess I am just screwed over $5.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
20명 중 15명(75%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
10.2 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 1월 5일
Very atmospheric horror point & click adventure.
Somehow you can feel the fright and tightness in the building you are trapped in.
Your job is to collect many occultic items, to proceed with certain rituals, read and listen the information that is given to you and await ghost randomly appearances. The beautiful soundtrack but especially the impressive sounds FX amplifier the horror and unforseen surprise. Unfortunately you must create a Calypso account before you can play this SP game (!).
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
18명 중 11명(61%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
1명이 이 평가가 재미있다고 함
비추천
1.4 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2015년 12월 4일
A rather disappointing adventure game with annoying puzzles that have some weird solutions. Quite nice atmosphere and visuals, but the gameplay is lacking, hence I cannot recommend this game to anyone.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
5명 중 4명(80%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
18.7 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 2월 24일
That's the last time I will buy a game with "mixed" reviews. The main problems are:
1/ The clunky menus. This is evident even when you start the game. It takes about 16 mouse clicks to get going EACH TIME, which shows the designers simply have no concept of the player experience. Game play is largely ruined by constantly having to deselect inventory items, click through unnecessary text which blocks all other mouse actions, and closing the inventory by typing "i" instead of escape, all clicks requiring a little delay before the next action will work.

2/ I didn't find the pixel hunting too bad, but there is far too much randomly trying things in the inventory as some of the "solutions" are counter-intuitive. I am a seasoned adventure game player and like to play without walkthroughs but this just isn't worth the effort of doing so.

The game isn't bad looking but the "atmospheric sounds" feel like they just threw in random effects for a bonus. That's really the problem, it just doesn't feel genuine, it's too formulaic. The real giveaway is the trite writing in the diary, which reads like a schoolkid exercise. Give it a miss.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
2명 중 2명(100%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
6.1 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2016년 1월 13일
Great game! Just disconnect from internet while launching to bypass Kalypso DRM.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
5명 중 3명(60%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
0.3 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2015년 12월 13일
It's sad because it's exactly the type of games I usually like; indie, atmospheric, adventure-puzzle.

- DRM - The game asks you to create an account, email address, etc. You need to insert the CD key EACH time you play (f**K you kalypso game).

- Lots of minor dysfunctional things makes the gaming experience painful and frustrating. Text is barely readable, controls are clumsy.

For me it's a waste of money.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
2명 중 1명(50%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
7.2 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2015년 12월 26일
Great game, creepy atmosphere and multiple game opportunities. I'm still working through another game after being unceremoniously dumped outside the house and having to start again!
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
Most Helpful Reviews  Overall
16명 중 15명(94%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
3.9 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2015년 4월 29일
단풍나무에는 여신이 살고 있습니다.

장점

+감미로운 사운드
+진실을 파헤치기 위한 8개의 멀티 엔딩
+컬트적 스토리 (및 스팀 트레이딩 카드와 스토리 연계)
+EE버전에서 수첩, 책, 단서가 추가되어 스토리 이해를 도움


단점

-3자 DRM
-불편한 조작감
-불친절한 게임성
-불필요한 체력 시스템
-접근성이 좋지 않은 퍼즐
-다회차 장려 컨텐츠 미비


주의점

스토리를 반드시 이해하셔야 게임과 동떨어진 사운드가 이해가 됩니다.


이런 분들에게 추천합니다.

오직 스토리 하나만 보기 위해 플레이하실 수 있으신 분
미스테리를 파헤치길 좋아하시는 분


이런 분들에게 비추천합니다.

불친절한 게임은 하기 힘드신 분
3D 울렁증이 있으신 분
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
12명 중 9명(75%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
12.7 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2015년 3월 10일
구매 경로
Kalypso Media(Humble Weekly Bundle, $1.00)

좋아
+그래픽
+BGM
+멀티 엔딩
+흥미로운 스토리

싫어
-불친절한 게임
-보기완 다르게 무섭지 않음
-좋지만 분위기에 어울리지 않는 BGM
-제 3자 DRM(Kalypso Launcher) 사용

5/10

한 줄 평
조금 더 친절했으면 어땠을까

수정: 2015.03.18. 평가 형식 교체
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
4명 중 4명(100%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
1.3 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2014년 1월 9일
너무 지릴것같아서 헤드셋 벗고 한 공포게임... 하라는 게임은 안하고 트레이딩 카드 셔틀로 전락한 비운의 게임?
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
6명 중 5명(83%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
추천
7.7 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2014년 11월 12일
솔직히 이쯤되면 주류의 게임회사가 독점하는 90년대의 게임산업 시장 체제는 끝난듯 하다. 무서운 인디들의 힘을 보여주는 작품. 인디이기에 더욱 빛을 바래는 작품들이 많이 나오는것 같다.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
6명 중 1명(17%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
비추천
0.4 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2014년 5월 17일
미친 이거 씨디키 입력창 않떠서 플레이 못해
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
150명 중 119명(79%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
1명이 이 평가가 재미있다고 함
비추천
7.3 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2014년 5월 27일
Anna-

It has an eerie story, a few "jump scares" that we're tastfully done, but overall the game wasn't fantastic. I spent a few hours banging my head against some of the puzzles, as even though you're given a LITTLE direction, it's not enough half the time. If you're looking for a pretty game, this is it. Anna has it's own DRM, along with Steam, which some might find obnoxious. I forced myself to 100% it, alot of it in offline mode.

I would have to give it a 4/10, it did spook me a few times and give me the "WTF is that?! OH ♥♥♥♥" moments. The story could of been a bit more fluffed, and the puzzles given a little more direction. I spent most of my time, wandering back and forth in areas for a bit trying to find that TINY clue I needed to move on.

I recommend googling a "Walkthrough/How-To" for this game when you get stuck, or go slowly your first playthrough. Pay attention to every tiny detail.

My opinion on the matter, this game could have been more.
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음
124명 중 101명(81%)이 이 평가가 유용하다고 함
5명이 이 평가가 재미있다고 함
비추천
2.9 시간 기록
게시 일시: 2015년 7월 16일
be weary, game uses DRM which requires you to register your email account before you can play this single player game....
That wouldn't be so bad if the log in launcher didn't tell you your product key was already in use if you don't play the game for a few months...
이 평가가 유용한가요? 아니요 재미있음