8/10 Never liked the souls genre, but this one was great. Open world helps you run past stuff that's too difficult and come back later. Makes all the difference. Lot of variety in combat and enemies

8/10 Phenomenal game. Story, dialogue, characters, world. It's all awesome. Combat is a bit repetitive, but it's forgivable when the rest of the game is so good.

6/10 I liked this game but didn't love it. The semi-open world was only semi-interesting, with typical MMO dead world problems. Wasn't drawn into the story, and my buddies didn't play so I burned out

9/10 One of my favorites of all time. Loved the characters, story, world, cowboy-sim gameplay. All of it. MP has always been plagued by cheaters, so I never enjoyed it at all. Could've been awesome.

6/10 It's all been said. Amazing game, with serious flaws. Hoped for an immersive RPG with branching paths. Got a beautiful (boring) world with a good (linear) story with violence as my only activity.

6/10 World design, acting, aesthetic, music...AWESOME Gameplay...suspenseful, yet tedious Kojima-ness...too much for me

5/10 There's fun to be had here in the main story, but the open world/exploration is a bit bland. Vehicle combat is average. Shooting feels weightless. Visuals are great. Story/characters are fun

7/10 Story was dumb but the gameplay was good. Visuals were fantastic. Wasn't really a fan of any of the characters. World design and monster variety were the high points.

7/10 Great FPS. Run, shoot, kill Nazis. Challenging at times, but not too bad. Story/characters in the home base sections are pretty cool. Story gets silly at the end, but that's Wolfenstein for ya

8/10 Fantastic RPG. Loses points just because of dated 'tactical' tab-target combat. Love the story/characters/dialogue. Lots of player choice and twists. Camp is fun as the party bonds develop more