Heya all!
Huge indie game fan here!
First I just want to thank the devs
but on that note the game.. sigh;
Pros:
The music is fantastic!
The commentary is AWESOME and funny esp the strongbad and suck a bag o... ahem well ull see
The backgrounds and arts are wonderful!
The voice acting is very nicely done
The neat little things like refection of the sun on the ocean, or a light above reflecting on the floor below are awesome additions, the snow falling etc wonderful and beautiful
The history lessons are fantastic too (without the commentary..as this dev loves to do and I THANK THEM FOR THIS) this game would rank 2/10 vs my final score of 5/10
Cons:
-The music commentary is 90% about the artist not about the game, very few commentary markers talk about the music IN this game but rather his childhood or ideals or other games he has done
-The game is REALLY short, 1-2 hours max, another 30 min or more if you listen to all commentary VERY VERY SHORT
-There are almost NO puzzles in this game whatsoever! The ones that do exist are frankly sad and pathetic
-The map and design of the game are poorly done, leaving you with 1-4 locations per time era and giving no real visual oooh and awwww! just bland bland bland
-The main character is a salesman of realestate zzzz really? urmm no.. yes ? ahh nooo
-The devs commentary goes to show that he himself knew very little about the era (one such point is making a newspaper machine vendor that took change and that wasnt invented yet and it took testers and friends to point that out)
-He also removed anything nice from the game due to it making the game to hard, such as the points to spend on persuasion, which that minigame is sad.. just save and reload and tadaaaaaa
I love this dev and publisher, I just hope that spending this much on a really bad game helps make a great game next round
bottom line:
I love to support the indie scene, with this game I had high hopes, was it fun, well yes and no.
Was it worth the 15$ .. heck no, but was it worth supporting this dev and publisher for future games YES YES YES!
Id love to give this game a neutral review but since there are more cons than pros, I have to say wait until it is on sale, unless like me you want to support the devs for a next game
Here is hoping they add more substance and better interfaces and actually have puzzles and depth in the next game!
dont buy this yet, but keep it on the wishlist for a pricedrop!
and go buy Quest for Infamy for the same price you get 60+ hours and much much better renders and bgs and animations and HUMOR oh yea and there are puzzles and paths to pick from unlike A GOLDEN WAKE which has the "ILLUSION OF CHOICE" bad move on the devs part to admit that in the commentary..
love you devs and please dont take this the wrong way, but this game, just a bad game..
felt like it coulda been a contender, but fell short on almost every mark