Daha fazla kargasa, daha fazla yikim, daha fazla Rufus. Bir degil, iki degil, üç Rufus uzun zamandir beklenen bul ve tikla macera komedisi Elveda Deponia’da her türlü çilgin kargasaya neden oluyor: Organon, Deponia'nin imhasini planliyor, sevimli Goal (bir kez daha) ortadan kaybolmus durumda ve anti-kahraman Rufus kendi bildigini...
İncelemeler: Çok Olumlu (366 inceleme)
Çıkış Tarihi: 17 Eki 2013

Bu oyunu istek listenize eklemek veya ilgilenmiyorum olarak işaretlemek için oturum açın

Goodbye Deponia Satın Alın

Goodbye Deponia Premium Satın Alın

Includes the soundtrack, concept art, deponia animation workbook and “Introduction to the Deponia world” book.

 

Küratörler Tarafından Öneriliyor

"The conclusion to an amazing adventure that we're surely going to miss."

Son güncellemeler Tümünü görüntüle (2)

14 Kasım

Goodbye Deponia Patch 3.2 scheduled for Monday 17.11.2014

Hi everyone,

we’re happy to announce that we are releasing the patch 3.2 for Goodbye Deponia on Monday 17th, 2014.

This update brings Goodbye Deponia to the engine and patch level of Deponia - The Complete Journey, containing performance improvements and several hundred bugfixes throughout the game. But that also means that you will need to re-download the whole game. Savegames will stay compatible.

Please note that there might be some bugs included in your savegames which can’t be solved by the patch. In that case, please contact our support team via support@daedalic.de. They have already prepared all potentially necessary savegames for you!

Changelog Goodbye Deponia 3.2

Fixed infinite Organon hymn loop problem
Fixed Rufus walking on the same spot on several places in chapter 8
Fixed Rufus leaving the walkmap in front of the rebel headquarter
Fixed possible plotstopper when giving the datadisc to another Rufus while being in Argus's laboratory
Added Linux platform

6 yorum Daha fazlasını oku

İncelemeler

“A cool story with many twists, relatively complex puzzles, but most of all the brilliant, omnipresent humor make Goodbye Deponia the best part of the trilogy - and Daedalic finally a worthy heir of LucasArts.”
9.5/10 – GamersGlobal

“Goodbye Rufus and goodbye Deponia. Even 20 years from now, I certainly will remember our trip fondly, telling everyone what a good ride we've had. You will be missed, but not forgotten. Farewell!”
9/10 – Gamereactor

“The dialogue, the bizarre characters and the slapstick humor measure up to those of 'Day of the Tentacle'.”
91% – GameStar

More games from the Deponia series!



Deponia: Available Content Packages Overview

Bu Oyun Hakkında

Daha fazla kargasa, daha fazla yikim, daha fazla Rufus. Bir degil, iki degil, üç Rufus uzun zamandir beklenen bul ve tikla macera komedisi Elveda Deponia’da her türlü çilgin kargasaya neden oluyor: Organon, Deponia'nin imhasini planliyor, sevimli Goal (bir kez daha) ortadan kaybolmus durumda ve anti-kahraman Rufus kendi bildigini okumaktan vazgeçememis görünüyor.

Mucit ve özgür ruhlu Rufus'un tüm yapmak istedigi, hurdalik gezegeni Deponia'dan ayrilmak ve toplumun en üst kademeleri için ayrilan bir uzay gemisi olarak Deponia'nin yörüngesindeki cennet Elysium'a tasinmak. Rufus'un gönlünü kaptirdigi eski Elysian kizi olan Goal, çabasinin ve onu uzaya götürecek olan asansörün hala anahtari olarak görünüyor. Son olarak Rufus, mükemmel görünen bir plan ortaya atti.

Hal böyle olunca, büyük olasilikla ters gidebilecek her sey aniden ters gidiyor. Goal kayip iken, Rufus kendini Organon'un sert yüzlü yetkililerinin arasinda, bir otoyol gezinti aracinda (baslangiçta kilik degistirmis olarak) buluyor. Rufus bir klonlama makinesine rastladiginda, çikis yolunu bulmus olduguna inaniyor. Bir klon kopyasinin ona içinden çikilmaz durum konusunda yardim etmesi gerek. Ancak "açiklanamaz" bir hata komplikasyonlara neden oluyor ve Goal kahramanimizin elinden bir kez daha kayip gidiyor. Simdi, üç büyük sorunu çözmek zorunda: Goal'u tekrar bulmasi, Elysium'a ulasmasi ve Organon'un elinden tüm Deponia gezegeninin yok olmasini önlemesi gerek.

Sadece üç Rufus'un çözebilecegi üç sorun ve böylece, sanssiz mucit kendini klonlamak için karar veriyor! Bu, oyuncu için çilgin sonuçlara yol açiyor: Elveda Deponia'da, Rufus sik sik kendisine takilip tökezlemesine ragmen, birlikte görevleri tamamlamak için bunlari kullanarak oyuncunun zaman zaman her üç
Rufus'u kontrol etmesi gerek.

Elveda Deponia, Deponia üçlemesinin destansi sonu ve 2013 yili en iyi Alman oyununun devami (Alman Bilgisayar Oyunu Ödülleri).
Ödüllü Deponia serisi, hurdalik gezegen Deponia'dan gelen maceranin üç tuhaf hikâyesinden olusuyor. Bu klasik bul ve tikla haylazlari, sadece komedi tutkunlarini ve macera ustalarini degil, ayni zamanda bu türde yeni olanlari da eglendiriyor. Komik Deponia serisi güzel, elle çizilmis 2D çizgi roman grafikleri, alayci diyaloglari ve bol kara mizah ile iz birakiyor. Aralarinda Alman Bilgisayar Oyunu Ödülü (Deutscher Bundestag Besin Computerspielpreis) ve diger birçok Alman gelistirici ödülleri de bulunan çok sayida basin ödülü kazandi.

TEMEL ÖZELLIKLER


  • Douglas Adams, Terry Pratchett ve Matt Groening geleneginde, essiz bir dünyada klasik bir bul ve tikla macerasi
  • Memoria, Edna ve Harvey’in yapimcilarindan: Firar, Yeni Bir Baslangiç ve Edna ve Harvey: Harvey'in Yeni Gözleri
  • Ikonik Deponia serisine destanci bir son
  • Elle çizilmis HD 2D grafiklerle benzersiz çizgi roman tarzi
  • Sevgi ile gerçeklestirilen animasyonlarla bestelenmis ara sahneler

Sistem Gereksinimleri

Windows
Mac OS X
SteamOS + Linux
    Minimum:
    • OS: Windows XP/Vista/7/8
    • Processor: 2.5 GHz Single Core Processor or 2 GHz Dual Core Processor
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: OpenGL 2.0 compatible with 256 MB RAM (Shared Memory is not recommended)
    • Hard Drive: 3 GB available space
    • Additional Notes: Mouse
    Recommended:
    • OS: Windows Vista/7/8
    • Processor: 2.5 GHz Single Core Processor or 2 GHz Dual Core Processor
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: OpenGL 2.0 compatible with 512 MB RAM (Shared Memory is not recommended)
    • Hard Drive: 3 GB available space
    • Additional Notes: Mouse
    Minimum:
    • OS: Lion (10.7)
    • Processor: 2 GHz (Dual Core) Intel
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: 256 MB RAM
    • Hard Drive: 3 GB available space
    • Additional Notes: Mouse
    Minimum:
    • OS: Linux x86_64
    • Processor: 2.5 GHz Single Core Processor or 2 GHz Dual Core Processor
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: OpenGL 2.0 compatible with 256 MB RAM (Shared Memory is not recommended)
    • Hard Drive: 3500 MB available space
    • Sound Card: OpenAL compatible
    • Additional Notes: Mouse
Yararlı müşteri incelemeleri
8 kişiden 8 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 14.3 saat
Yayınlanma: 27 Ekim
how can this crazy, and funny game like this make me cry ..

this is awesome game.
trust me.
must buy deponia, chaos on deponia, and goodbye deponia ( deponia complete journey ).
this is epic game. really nice story,
you played as rufus , a crazy guy with a lot of wild plan to reach his dream.
but the ending is sad ..
:(

man i love rufus !!!
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
6 kişiden 6 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 18.2 saat
Yayınlanma: 23 Kasım
The Series Continues!

Deponia has been great, from start to finish. Which is something I’m happy to be able to say. There is nothing worse than a franchise that gets progressively worse the more sequels that are released. The Deponia series has managed to remain interesting and new.

First off, I have to admit this game wasn’t exactly what I expected for a number of reasons but none of which knocked points off. Despite any feelings at the time of playing through it I would still say this is one of my favourite point and click adventure series of all time.

Story wise, it was definitely enjoyable. It took unexpected turns a few times which was great but the ending for me was a little questionable, or at least it felt that way at the time. I would be utterly lying if I said that it ended how I imagined it would.
I’m ill and half brain dead at the moment so naturally… I got confused and I cried. As you do. But I would say it was just unexpected and in all honesty I’m not even sure I know what was going on. It wasn’t even necessarily bad or upsetting!

I noticed a very subtle difference in language that was used in this one, the characters swear every now and again. It was a little bit of a shock the first time but it was actually really amusing the way they did it. The characters are as loveable as ever, both main characters and side characters. I especially like their re-use of more insignificant characters.

Voicing, sound effects and music is pretty much the same throughout the series (you notice a jump up in quality from first to second but the third is pretty much the same as the second) but I think it fits well, you start recognising certain music to mean certain things to get you a little more engrossed or emotional over the situations in which they are used. Definitely doesn’t come across as lazy or recycling.

As always with point and clicks there is always places where you get stuck, or there is a somewhat un-logical solution to a puzzle that you come across that ends up being frustrating. Deponia manages to keep a good balance between the items you use together being creative but logical. I got stuck quite a lot during this third one I won’t lie. At one point you are controlling 3 different characters that can influence each other and maybe that is why I was having such a hard time. You are essentially playing 3 different point and click games at once. Maybe it’s just because I’m brain dead at the moment being ill, but I found this third game harder than either of the previous ones.

Achievement wise, there is definitely a lot more in this one then there was in the last 2, or at least it felt that way. It took me a total of 18 hours to complete this game 100% and that includes about 2 and a half playthroughs. Admittedly I might have been able to do it in less if I was paying proper attention but I completed the game causally the first time around.

Quick shout out to the chorus guys, a very charming part of the series being the singing between chapters. I always look forward to their songs. But all in all it’s a great game and a great franchise that I have come to be very fond of. I’d say definitely go for it.


TL;DR : A great end to the series. Engaging story, fun puzzles, great humour, wonderful art, loveable characters, good music/other media and easy to 100%. It’s a done deal!


For anyone interested, My Review for Deponia:
http://steamcommunity.com/id/Stefneh/recommended/214340

For anyone interested, My Review for Chaos on Deponia:
http://steamcommunity.com/id/Stefneh/recommended/220740/
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
2 kişiden 2 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 24.7 saat
Yayınlanma: 28 Ekim
Goodbye Deponia, the 3rd and final game in the Deponia trilogy. To be honest, when I finished Chaos on Deponia I simply didn't want to believe I was about to finish a so far amazing trilogy. I had a lot of fun with Goodbye Deponia, and it's probably my favorite in the trilogy. There is just one thing about the game that I cannot stand but I am sure that everybody has previously mentioned. The ending. I just finished the game about 10 minutes ago and I really don't know what to say about the ending. I'll summarize the ending with 2 words; BULL. ♥♥♥♥. I really dislike the ending of this game, I was really starting to enjoy it. Especially after the speech and the Organon hymne, but nonetheless the ending is complete and utter crap for a game this good.
*SPOILERS*
So basically, after Argus, Cletus, and Rufus are all stuck in the Rotor, Goal comes and is confused (of course) of which one she should save cause the 3 all look alike
First of all I call ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
While Cletus and Argus may look very similar
Rufus is more tan, doesn't have a goatee like Cletus and Argus but I digress.
Goal ends up saving Cletus letting the real Rufus fall.
Like ♥♥♥♥ are you kidding me?
But anyway for an ending of a single game I might accept this, but for an ending to a TRILOGY? Where you're definitely not going to make another game in the series? No. Absolutely not.
Despite this ending I am really sad to see this series go. It was a fun ride throughout it.
I recommend Goodbye Deponia, BUT only after playing the first 2 games because you'll have absolutely no idea what is going on.

To summarize:

Pros: Pretty much everything, the graphics, the soundtrack, the humor, the colorful cast of characters, the locations, the unique puzzles, the drama.

Cons: The ending. If you loved the game throughout the whole journey, you'll be a bit disappointed

I'm honestly sad and surprised to have ended this series
Only thing I can say now is

Huzzah, I'm off now, goodbye!




EDIT: After now thinking about it, I don't dislike the ending as much as I did when I first viewed it. If anything, the ending just gets me choked up because of the music at the end reminding me how much fun I had with the trilogy. Overall, I still recommend the game, but don't expect a happy ending because the whole trilogy had sad endings, this one being the saddest hitting you like a truck when you actually realize that Rufus did and DIDN'T deserve to be on Elysium because frankly, he was an ♥♥♥, but throughout the games, he did all that he could but people still doubted him and trash talked him, and when he was just a jump from Elysium he sacrificed himself, just so he could give his "friends" a better life, just so he could prove them wrong, like Goal said, there were so many opportunities where he could've gone to Elysium with her but he didn't. Just because he cared too much about his fellow Deponians, so in the end he sacrificed it all, so he didn't get to Elysium after all, so what? I mean we were all hoping it but as I've heard from other fans of the games they have said that Daedelic games always have unhappy endings, but hey that's just what I've heard, if you want to find out for yourself, buy the first game and try it out, as for me, I still whole heartedly recommend the trilogy and it is a fantastic series that I will always hold close to my heart.
I just hope Daedelic gives some closure on wheter Rufus survives or not, granted he did fall from a huge distance into a pile of needles and survived but I digress. TO END MY LONG EDIT,

I'm off now for real.
"Huzzah he's off now for real!"

the ending will always give me feels ;~:
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
1 kişiden 1 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 16.6 saat
Yayınlanma: 4 Kasım
Great end to a great series! Very few series catch my emotional side like this one does, and I'm honored to have played all 3 deponia games. I was moved. My only complaint?

I wish, after beating it, we could unlock an alternate ending or two. I don't want to ruin the ending at all, but there could have easily been 2 different endings, if not more - but the game is done so well, I truly am honored to have witnessed this amazing piece of art.

Thank you for the amazing game! May Deponia live on forever! Because we are in fact, all asses.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
1 kişiden 1 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 12.3 saat
Yayınlanma: 15 Kasım
Again it had some infuriating puzzles. The kids and I enjoyed solving them anyway.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
1 kişiden 1 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 5.4 saat
Yayınlanma: 17 Kasım
Better than episode 2, on par with the first in terms of enjoyment. Loved the major plot twist.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
1 kişiden 0 tanesi (0%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 20.1 saat
Yayınlanma: 10 Kasım
Truly the best of the trilogy. Incredibly witty, great story, and a wonderful end to the trilogy. Highly recomended.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
11 kişiden 10 tanesi (91%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 11.0 saat
Yayınlanma: 8 Eylül
Hayatınızda oynayabileceğiniz en eğlenceli oyunlardan bir tanesi ve Deponia üçlemesinin son oyunu. Point and Click oyunlarının zirve yaptığı noktalardan birisi. Puzzle yapısındaki oyunları sevmeseniz bile size sevdirecek bir oyun. Karakterler arasındaki mizahi konuşmalar çok ileri seviyede. Eğer kütüphanenizdeki yüzlerce oyuna bakıp oynuyacak hiçbir oyunun yok diyorsanız Deponia serisinin birinci oyunundan başlayıp sonuncusuna kadar oynayın. Oyunu babam yapsa bu kadar övemezdim.

9/10
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
3 kişiden 2 tanesi (67%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 15.0 saat
Yayınlanma: 23 Temmuz
Bu inceleme, Deponia üçlemesindeki her oyunu kapsamaktadır.

Zaten oyunlar tek başına bir anlam ifade etmiyor, çünkü birbirini takip eden konulardan oluşan bir seri. Edna and Harvey ile tanıdığım Deadalic, çıtayı çok çok daha yükseğe çekmiş. Güzel esprilerle, ince düşünülmüş detaylarla, mükemmel tasarlanmış karakterleriyle ve hoş bir senaryoyla bir point and click oyunun sahip olması gereken her özelliğe sahip.

Ayrıca bulmacaları ideal zorlukta. Bir çok point and click oyunda bulmacalar kafayı yedirtecek seviyede zordur, bazılarında ise zevk vermeyecek kadar basit. Bu seride kesinlikle bu dengeyi çok güzel kurmuşlar.

9/10
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
8 kişiden 7 tanesi (88%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 15.1 saat
Yayınlanma: 8 Ekim
This is the 3rd game in the Deponia Trilogy.

Pros: Great animation, good soundtrack, beautiful background art, excellent detail in almost every scene, double-click to fast travel, skippable puzzles, good voice acting, the story is brought to a close.

Cons: The solutions that Rufus has come up with to overcome obstacles in the previous games were never friendly to his fellow man (or animal), but he gets particularly nasty in this game. While this game is a dark comedy, anyone who is extra-sensitive to real-world social issues will be offended by some of the events in this episode.

Summary: If you played and enjoyed the other 2 games, then play this one! If you cannot stomach dark humor of the Southpark variety, you're better off not playing this one.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
5 kişiden 5 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 11.1 saat
Yayınlanma: 13 Temmuz
The epic 3-part adventure comes to an end... or does it?
It'll make you laugh and you'll be sad to let the characters go when all is said and clicked. I'm missing those guys already.
If you liked the first two games getting this one is a no-brainer.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
4 kişiden 4 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 12.6 saat
Yayınlanma: 28 Eylül
Goodbye Deponia is a satisfying conclusion to Daedalic's trilogy.

It has the imaginative puzzles of the first Deponia, a satisfying move away from the terrible puzzles of Chaos on Deponia. It's lengthier than the previous offerings so there is a great deal more to do, some locations from the previous games are revisited albeit in the form of different areas of those places. and most importantly Rufus, is still a ♥♥♥♥♥♥bag but is not nearly so callous as in the previous games, a final recognition of his character development. HOwever As for Argus and Cletus, well once again Daedalic fail somewhat there, in fact the largest rub I've had with the Deponia games is the lack of true understanding of their characters psychology. Daedalic tend to go for gags and tropes with the characters there to fill in the holes. This is unfortunately very apparent. It's a pity the writers have focused on the humour more than on their character motivations, it does seem to be improving however as they have gained in experience through the series.
The bizarre Piers Anthony humour still abounds, and the game has a plethora of pop culture references to find and discover.
The quirky art style is still just as appropriate to the underlying themes, and the vibrant, mechanisticly lush environments are as wonderful as ever. The music (much of it rehashed from previous games) is enjoyable without becoming overwhelming. As for the Chorus Guys... well their lyrics are still just as awkward to try and "sing"...

Overall I will recommennd the game, however it needs to be played with Deponia and Chaos on Deponia as well, so if possible try buy it as a part of a package deal, and not standalone.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
3 kişiden 3 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 17.1 saat
Yayınlanma: 13 Eylül
Best Point-and-Click adventure i have ever played.
SO sad that there is not one more Deponia part ;(

100/10 LOve this Game ;)
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
7 kişiden 5 tanesi (71%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 11.2 saat
Yayınlanma: 24 Ekim
9/10
The end of the trilogy. Jokes are darker, stakes are higher, and we see if Rufus can EVER change.
If you liked the first two, you'll like this one, or you're the sort of whiney kid who shouldn't have played the others.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
2 kişiden 2 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 18.5 saat
Yayınlanma: 13 Temmuz
This game is part of just about one of the best point and click series around. The series as a whole is pretty fantastic aside from a few issues that I have with it. Unfornatly I honestly hope that this wasn't the end. The ending which I was hopeing for so much the happy one that would reflect well on the whole seires wasn't there. You sit through seeing all the things that the main character does just waiting for him to finaly earn his happy ending then bam nope. I get the point was to show that he had changed and that he wasn't the same person and he had done this all for goal. BUT COME ON. Honestly I got done with playing this game and was thinking "Why did I bother?" Its worth a play because its a great game but honestly the ending is total rubbish.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
2 kişiden 2 tanesi (100%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 15.8 saat
Yayınlanma: 10 Ağustos
I will always recommend this series. It's up there in my favorites of all time.
That said, this game made me disgusted with myself for some of the things Rufus did, and then made me see the better side of him all in one. There is so much room for growth... And so few answers. Please make a 4, and answer some of them. Please.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
4 kişiden 3 tanesi (75%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 12.1 saat
Yayınlanma: 1 Temmuz
This game with all its fun art, quality music and witty umor, let me down on the ending. No spoilers but it was a bummer, not that it did not have some redeemable heroic aspects for the ending and some mild closure, it left me wanting some specific things that I think we all would expect for Goal and Rufus' relationship. Somebody decided to opt for a more uncommon or "what if?" and slightly tragic ending, than what we were all looking forward to. Oh well...that being said, I did have some great humorous experiences from the three games, just don't get attached to any of the characters and expect something like you would see in the end of a interesing/humorous Japanese anime love story, that just never ends up right and most always ends up leaving the audience confused or wanting for a happier conclusion or a conclusion at all. Eye of Satinav series at least takes that aspect (and frankly values its audiences time more) into consideration for its players, and in the end they are more satified for it. Enjoy! So I will recommend this game only for the aspect of storyline conclusion.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
4 kişiden 3 tanesi (75%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 15.9 saat
Yayınlanma: 5 Eylül
Absolutely fantastic, Rufus's antics never cease to amuse and the feelings were very intense in this game. This is my favorite series hands down and it was very bittersweet to finally finish the final installment. I suggest anyone and everyone give this series a chance, it will not disappoint!

Goodbye, Deponia, I will sorely miss you.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
5 kişiden 3 tanesi (60%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 10.5 saat
Yayınlanma: 11 Ağustos
A great and fitting ending to a most entertaining adventure trilogy. Highly reccommended to everyone who appreciates a good yarn!
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır
5 kişiden 3 tanesi (60%) bu incelemeyi yararlı buldu
kayıtlarda 9.5 saat
Yayınlanma: 3 Ekim
The feel of old Lucasart in all its glory. Loved every one in rhe trilogy.
Bu inceleme yararlı oldu mu? Evet Hayır