Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.
User reviews: Very Positive (1,114 reviews) - 93% of the 1,114 user reviews for this game are positive.
Release Date: Sep 29, 2014

Sign in to add this item to your wishlist, follow it, or mark it as not interested

Buy Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

 

Reviews

“I have to believe Holmes would approve.”
8/10 – Polygon

“Thrilling detective-game ... even Moriaty would play it!”
85/100 – GameStar

“Hands down the best detective game I've ever played and one of the most enjoyable experiences of the 2014 gaming year so far.”
9,5/10 – Hooked Gamers

They reviewed Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

About This Game

Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.

Will you follow your moral compass, or will you apply the letter of the law?

The great freedom of action in Crimes & Punishments allows you to conduct your investigations in the manner you deem appropriate. Use the 14 extraordinary skills of detection for which Sherlock is famous, choose the avenues of enquiry you wish to pursue, interrogate your suspects and, from your deductions, name the guilty parties... you can even determine their fate! The ramifications are far-reaching, and your decisions will exert a real influence through your reputation or the surprising consequences that will arise where you least expect them…

System Requirements

    Minimum:
    • OS: WINDOWS VISTA SP2/WINDOWS 7/WINDOWS 8
    • Processor: AMD/INTEL DUAL-CORE 2.4 GHZ
    • Memory: 2048 MB RAM
    • Graphics: 256 MB 100% DIRECTX 9 COMPATIBLE AMD RADEON HD 3850/NVIDIA GEFORCE 8600 GTS OR HIGHER
    • DirectX: Version 9.0c
    • Storage: 14 GB available space
    • Sound Card: DIRECTX 9 COMPATIBLE
    • Additional Notes: INTERNET CONNECTION REQUIRED FOR THE GAME ACTIVATION
Helpful customer reviews
32 of 34 people (94%) found this review helpful
24.9 hrs on record
Posted: January 13
This is the perfect Sherlock Holmes game. In Crimes and Punishments, you have six cases to solve, and its completely up to you to deduce the facts, and bring about judgment. Oh there is so much goodness where to start? The game is gorgeous. Victorian England never looked so good. The amount of different places you get to visit is amazing, from beautiful mansions to seedy back alleys. The voice acting is superb. Also, the voice synch is perfect. What I really love about this game is that after finishing a case, you can always come back when you want to do another case, without worrying if they are connected in any way. Each case comes with so many different possibly outcomes, if you find the evidence and come to certain conclusions. How you sentence who you believe is guilty also influences how the public sees you. The in-game journal is wonderful in helping you keep track of who is involved in the case, what items can help you advance the case, or look back at a dialogue that may have a clue. So the good stuff in a nutshell: The Look, the writing and the acting, the Game Mechanics, and the Stories of each Case. The negatives: I can't find them.
This is a great game to start with if you are interested in the Sherlock Holmes franchise. If you have already played through the catalog available of SH titles, I dare say you must play this because I think you'll find this to be arguably the best SH games to date.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
50 of 64 people (78%) found this review helpful
1 person found this review funny
13.0 hrs on record
Posted: September 26, 2015
Everything about this game is fantastic except for the arbitrary nature of the deduction system. There will typically be at least three solutions with separate suspects and different means of having committed the crime. The different clues which have been collected during the investigation must be arranged to form different deductions in order to single out the perpetrator. The system is genius except for the fact, that the developers have failed to make some deductions more correct or coherent than others. Thus you can never be sure your chosen solution - based on solid reasoning (what Sherlock Holmes is supposed to be all about!) - will be correct. Even if you have taken all things into considerations and logically chosen the most likely explanation. This have been incredibly frustrating and immersion breaking.

To further explain what I mean by the solution being arbitrary, I will provide the following observation:
Any case in "Crimes & Punishments" will have established means, motives and opportunities for all suspects, if you diligently have found all the different clues. The problem as I see it is, that there should at least be some few things that makes one suspect more likely than the other, or deductions that stood out as far less sound, as they appeared to be in conflict with other circumstances like causality or the existence of contradictory evidence, but no. All the solutions are equal in likelihood and reasoning, and as Sherlock Holmes we are bound to make a decision on who we would most wish to see having committed the crime or who we intuitively believe did the crime based on knowledge of crime cliches.
It seams the developers have constructed the clues, deductions and solutions in order to fit the model of "means, motives and opportunities" as conditions in order to establish guilt as found in common law legal systems. This still only provides a dissatisfying experience, as this doesn't prove the actual guilt of the suspect, which in turn today nor in Victorian era Britain were enough to lift the needed burden of prof of having committed a crime. Establishing the presence of these three elements is not, in and of itself, sufficient to provide a conviction beyond reasonable doubt; the evidence must prove that an opportunity presented was indeed taken by the suspect and for the crime with which he or she is charged. In "Crimes & Punishments" the different solutions are entirely equal in probability, and this is the prime weakness of the system: If all the suspects can be reasoned to be equally as likely the ones who committed the crime, then they are all equally as unlikely to be guilty, and in a court of law this would actually make providing a conviction impossible. The conclusion simply cannot be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.

It frustrates and saddens me, that the deduction system have been built in such a way as the solutions are wholly arbitrary and in total disconnect with the books of sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Mainly because if you can ignore this, then the game is fantastic. The atmosphere is fantastic and the locations and voice acting is great.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
16 of 16 people (100%) found this review helpful
12.9 hrs on record
Posted: February 1
Much more polished and better in almost every way than the previous game(s). All minigames are now skippable, but they're also easier so you probably won't need to skip them. Graphically improved, especially faces are really well done. Lip sync is fixed now, after seeming off in the Testament. The game is divided in six separate cases that allow you to solve them in multiple ways and also give you some moral choices. My favorite case is #2 - the missing train, which is strangely also the only case I didn't solve correctly - I nailed the 'who', but missed the 'how' after stupidly changing my deduction because of some clue conflicts. And the game let me do this and continue, which is great. There are some new mechanics that work to make you feel like the legendary detective by showing how he gets to his conclusions.

This time you can only play in first or third person, the point & click mode is gone. I guess that's a plus, since there are no items that are really hard to even spot while playing in first-person mode.

My only gripes are the new Watson VA - he's okay, but the previous one just nailed it, and the cab cutscene that shows when you travel between locations that for some reason really bothered me, I'd prefer a loading screen instead.
Also I became 'stuck' several times, had to mash WASD to unstuck myself. No big deal tho.


Overall, an improvement over the previous game in almost all aspects.

3.5 golden sloths
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
21 of 25 people (84%) found this review helpful
16 people found this review funny
14.1 hrs on record
Posted: December 5, 2015
I feel that my deductive skills have increased.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
25 of 34 people (74%) found this review helpful
3 people found this review funny
20.7 hrs on record
Posted: October 20, 2015
Best LA Noire Substitute :)
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny