Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.
User reviews: Very Positive (583 reviews)
Release Date: Sep 29, 2014

Sign in to add this item to your wishlist, follow it, or mark it as not interested

Buy Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

DAILY DEAL! Offer ends in


Recommended By Curators

"Rough around the edges, and with some bad puzzles, but this is an atmospheric detective adventure that actually lets you do some detecting."
Read the full review here.


“I have to believe Holmes would approve.”
8/10 – Polygon

“Thrilling detective-game ... even Moriaty would play it!”
85/100 – GameStar

“Hands down the best detective game I've ever played and one of the most enjoyable experiences of the 2014 gaming year so far.”
9,5/10 – Hooked Gamers

They reviewed Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

About This Game

Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.

Will you follow your moral compass, or will you apply the letter of the law?

The great freedom of action in Crimes & Punishments allows you to conduct your investigations in the manner you deem appropriate. Use the 14 extraordinary skills of detection for which Sherlock is famous, choose the avenues of enquiry you wish to pursue, interrogate your suspects and, from your deductions, name the guilty parties... you can even determine their fate! The ramifications are far-reaching, and your decisions will exert a real influence through your reputation or the surprising consequences that will arise where you least expect them…

System Requirements

    • Processor: AMD/INTEL DUAL-CORE 2.4 GHZ
    • Memory: 2048 MB RAM
    • DirectX: Version 9.0c
    • Hard Drive: 14 GB available space
    • Sound Card: DIRECTX 9 COMPATIBLE
Helpful customer reviews
82 of 87 people (94%) found this review helpful
2 people found this review funny
19.5 hrs on record
Posted: March 28
One of my favorite games from 2014, and probably my all time favorite detective game is this. Crimes and Punishment is a blast to play! The new engine offers breathtaking views and stunning textures, and the voice acting is fantastic. You have to make moral choices in this game, which affects the story.

The cases are much more interesting in this game then the previous Sherlock games, thanks to great mission variation. Solve murders, investigate thefts and missing people. "Will you follow the law or your moral?", is the question you have to go by on every case.

Every case is smart and well thought out. You always think you understand who did the crime, until it suddenly turns the other way around. When you finally complete a case you feel satisfied though. You will look around for a long time, just because you want to find every clue. If you get stuck you can get hints, look in your journal and ask doctor Watson.

I think this game is very underrated. It's one of the most polished games released in 2014 and offers a great story with absolutely fantastic cases. If you haven't picked this game up yet, please consider doing it. I really hope Frogware will release more content for this game. DLC, expansion or sequel, because I adore the game and would really wish for more great and exciting cases to solve.

Crimes and Punishment gets a warm recommendation from me.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
39 of 44 people (89%) found this review helpful
24.2 hrs on record
Posted: December 7, 2014
I picked up this game while looking for an old school point and click. It's not that at all. It's more like an interactive story with a few added case solving mechanics and mini games. This will really annoy a lot of die hard fans of the old Sierra or LucasArts games so you should really look at a video walthrough of the first few minutes before getting it. Usually I'd put myself in that class but I found the sheer entertainment value of this game is one of the best I've come across.

Best points:
Excellent visuals and voice acting,
Properly laugh out loud moments alongside the more serious plots.
20-25 hours of gameplay. Worth the high price.
Perfectly designed characters. Whoever scripted Watson is a genius.
Interesting and fun mechanics for deduction analysis and a few other minigames

Bad points
Very little challenge in puzzles or deduction
The transfer time between locations is painfully slow
No save games. You can replay chapter endings but otherwise nothing
Some minigames have horribly clunky interfaces.
Some of the pathing is a bit irritating. Most often Watson gets in your way and its a fight to get aound him to where your next clue is.

If you want a bit more detail...
The only people who I would advise to stay away from this are those solely interested in puzzle based old school point and click games.

The game is made up of 6 chapters, each based around an original Holmes story so they inherit some good writing. In each you walk Holmes around crime related scenes picking up clues, questioning suspects and doing research. This gives you thoughts which you have to link together correctly to make deductions that you tie together to solve a case. It is a fun mechanic but the deductions are sometimes too obvious. o=One or two are nonsensical. There's a bit of embarrassingly bad science in some minigames too but if you can get over that then the dialogue, characters and plot make this really good entertainment.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
17 of 20 people (85%) found this review helpful
17.1 hrs on record
Posted: May 25
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments is a game that consists of 6 playable mysterious cases of the world famous detective.

Gameplay 8.5 of 10
The game captures the feel of the Victorian London quite well, the whole environment design is really detailed, including tapestry, pictures on the wall, clothes and manner of speaking. You collect pieces of evidence and use Sherlock Holmes power of deduction to come to a reasonable conclusion and uncover the truth. But be aware, can come to the right conclusion? Or are you going to verdict an innocent man? Sometimes you know quite fast who did the crime, but how can you prove it? Use all of your senses. Smell , vision and hearing and if you can't find the conclusion yourself , you can get help from Sherlock Holmes dog Toby and sometimes you can also switch characters ,so you can play as Watson. You can also reenact some crimes in your mind to see if the witness’s statements are conclusive.

Graphics 8 of 10
The graphics are really good, you can even see dust particles in the air. The unreal engine really did do some good for the game. Especially the faces, when you interrogating the witness. You almost can’t tell they are game characters. They look so real.

Sound 8 of 10
There is slight background music, a little mellow, but fitting the scenery perfect and sometimes it's adding suspense. The voice acting is top notch. The English actors are truly good and really make you feel like you are in England at that time.

I played some of the other Sherlock Holmes games and this feels like it could be one of my favorites. So I would definitely recommend it to every adventure gamer who likes a good story and engaging puzzles.Every for gamers who are just starting out , this is a good way to start into adventures and point-and-click games.

Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
12 of 13 people (92%) found this review helpful
8.1 hrs on record
Posted: January 1
Playing Crimes and Punishments forces you to think, and place yourself in the place of Sherlock Holmes. Unlike most linear adventure games, this game only guides you to enough clues to form a few very possible conclusions; afterwards, you must use your own judgement to decide between them.

Let me give you an example:

Upon recovering all the clues in the first story, I was left with three possible solutions, two of which were more possible than the first. Instead of allowing you to follow up on those suspects, the game flat out refuses to allow you to investigate further and essentially tells you: "That's enough, its time for you to think like Sherlock Holmes and figure it out yourself"

The game sets up the cases such that the solutions are possible, so you'll have to make a judgement call and establish what posulations are plausible and which solutions to commit to. It was quite nerve wraking at first.

Admitedly, the gameplay is not perfect. There are frequent load pages (though you are able to review your deductions and notes on these pages, which is nice) and there's an element of pixel hunting. It's also a slow and methodical game except for the occassional minigame or Quick Time Event.

All in all, I would recommend this to someone who enjoys a slow puzzle. Perhaps someone who might enjoy a game like "The Vanishing of Ethan Carter". Since the game is rather methodical and slow, I would really aim to recommend it to a specific sect of puzzle loving adventure fans, whose main draw to adventure games isn't the comedy (if you love Sam and Max because of Sam and Max, this probably isn't for you).
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
13 of 15 people (87%) found this review helpful
1 person found this review funny
15.6 hrs on record
Posted: January 5
How did I wait until 2015 to play a Sherlock Holmes game? I picked this up on the Steam winter sale and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I haven't played the previous games in the series so my only references are other games, but this one in particular is very close to what Telltale does. There are six cases, each roughly two or three hours in length.

If you like adventure games of either the point and click variety or Telltale's modern franchises, this is an easy recommendation.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
12 of 14 people (86%) found this review helpful
14.9 hrs on record
Posted: December 14, 2014
It's a good game. The ability to decide whodunit is an awesome feature. However, while Testament of Sherlock Holmes was occasionally very confusing and difficult, I felt this game went too far in the opposite direction, where most of the puzzles and clues were fairly simple. Having six cases to solve is a good thing (the train one was my favorite), though it didn't allow for a deep plot to unravel like in Testament. Regardless, it's still a fun game and improved graphics are always appreciated. While the environments may just be average, characters' faces, in particular, are very detailed.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
20 of 29 people (69%) found this review helpful
1 person found this review funny
28.9 hrs on record
Posted: December 24, 2014
If you want to become an investigator Buy this game

you will not regret if you like kind of this and awesome graphics :)
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
20 of 31 people (65%) found this review helpful
2 people found this review funny
24.7 hrs on record
Posted: April 4
The game is visually stunning and manages to capture the atmosphere of late 19th century London and the surrounds extraordinarily well.

The visuals themselves are most definitely the greatest part of the game, and as a series of sequences of eye-candy the game tends to work rather well.

Where the game falls down is the actual gameplay, however. It is rather fun initially to run around sniffing out clues and talking to people, however this becomes repetitive rather quickly. There's very little available to actually challenge the player, as it's more or less a point-and-click to find the clues then these clues simply describe and fit themselves into the overall puzzle.

There were an entire range of different aspects that I would have rather focused on in each of the cases if it was a more free-world kind of game, however the game simply guides you towards conclusions. As a mental exercise the game is therefore practically worthless, which is a pity considering it is about one of the more intellectually gifted characters of the modern world.

The inability of the player to actually go wrong anywhere except in the final conclusion does rather reduce the level of reward the game can offer.

As a relaxing little piece of visuals flitting across your screen the game works well. However at $40 the price is rather steep. I would price the value of this game at about $15-$25, depending on what you're looking for. If you're more interested in nice visuals and atmospheric gameplay then you might be willing to fork out a bit.

If you're more interested in strong gameplay and a mental challenge rather pick up one of Paradox Intereactive's games for half the price, wait for this to go on sale (like, 50%-75%), or play a game of chess.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
7 of 7 people (100%) found this review helpful
18.8 hrs on record
Posted: April 2
As someone who has played many Sherlock Holmes games, I was delighted by the updated interface, and puzzles. While not perfect ( a few graphics glitches) it is quite the improvement from earlier releases.

- New puzzle styles offer different ways of arriving at conclusions
- Deduction board allows you to come to wrong conclusions
- Special skills allow you to "see" the world as Sherlock Holmes does
- Moral choice at the end of each case to see how you want to handle things

- Loading time can be excruciating, but they do allow you to review your casebook and deduction board which helps to mitigate the pain
- Price is a bit steep, so I waited until the game was on sale
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
8 of 9 people (89%) found this review helpful
12.5 hrs on record
Posted: December 27, 2014
Some thoughts on Sherlock: Crimes and Punishments

The advertising for this is probably a bit misleading, what with the lead characters dressed in modern attire and some sort of darker trailers. But make no mistake, this is a pretty classical Sherlock game set in the original time period (the modern clothes are just an unlockable) and a sequel to Frogware's other adventures with the character. I don't have too much experience with the older games, finding them a bit obtuse and clunky at times. Crimes and Punishments is their attempt to get the series some broader appeal, and it largely works. Controls are simplified but without sacrificing too much of the formula.

The game takes place over six cases, all mostly standalone so it has a pretty episodic feel to it. There's a small running plotline about a "terrorist" group called the Merry Men that runs throughout but is mostly just background filler. I've lamented on here about how there's not many games that actually make you feel like a detective, and this game is one that does. For starters, every case has multiple suspects, and you can actually draw the wrong conclusions and condemn an innocent person if you're not careful. Each suspect you choose also has variations on how you handle their fate. A cold blooded murderer you might want to send to the gallows, while someone acting in self defense you might be kinder too. The actual murder weapons and motives can play into these endings too if you get them wrong, so each case has at least like 6 endings. That is where the title comes in, their crimes, your punishments.

The games does clearly try to ape the modern BBC series a bit, with a focus on profiling characters from the fact they have callused or danity hands, or a telegram sticking out of their pocket. It actually does a good job of making you think like Holmes, and you start to actually be able to guess what he learns from these profiles before he says it. That's actually I think one of the best accomplishments of the game. It kind of immerses you in the minutiae. Using Holmes' analysis table on Baker Street is kind of a laborious affair, often having puzzles that in most games would probably include half the steps. But I'll be darned if they didn't manage to sucker me in with the use of pipettes to test various chemicals. You will also need to browse Holmes' large collection of newspapers, research, and encyclopedias when you see or hear about say, a robbery in 1889 rather than just asking someone about it. You'll even get to control Watson and his dog Toby at various points in the game.

There are couple minigames that are busts, often ones requiring aiming or precision, which is not a surprise given the developer's pedigree. Most of the voice acting is well done, if a bit theatrical (Sherlock himself gets pretty hammy at times, but it is largely amusing). Some of the stories are a bit basic, even if they provide a good mystery at first. Graphics are pretty great for the most part, thought that's largely thanks to most areas being pretty small. You can "customize" Sherlock but those options are actually pretty limited. Most of the options are only available when the story gives an option to disguise yourself to get information, which are pretty rare.

Anyways, if you like adventure games, snag this when you can. Much better than I anticipated.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
12 of 17 people (71%) found this review helpful
3 people found this review funny
18.4 hrs on record
Posted: January 31
Crimes and Punishments is an adequate rom thru late 1800’s London and the surrounding areas that both pushes the adventure genre in some new and interesting directions. Each case plays out like a short story on a book; they aren’t necessary related to one another but new cases aren’t unlock until the previous one is completed. Though the mysteries themselves don’t become more complex, the mini games like lock picking and puzzles to unlock clues do become more difficult. The games starts off on the right foot with a wonderful grizzle murder mystery with the victim impaled on the wall by his own wailing harpoon. It’s the perfect way to introduce players to the games interviewing puzzle mechanics. Interviewing suspects and witnesses lead to new clues, but physical clues in the environments or by inspecting what NPC’s are wearing and how they hold themselves can help catch someone in a lie or in a contradiction. This quick inspection of what each characters wearing is clearly inspired by BBC series and it works well in the videogame setting. But clues aren’t all found by grilling witnesses, a large portion of the game involves searching the environment. As clues and stories start to piece together, Crimes and Punishments opens up the synapse deduction system which chains the collaborating stories and physical clues and brings them to a logical conclusion. Each case has multiple outcomes, all of which have solid evidence to backups your suspicions. Once you come to a personally satisfactory conclusion as to who you think guilty is and you then ask whether or not that person is morally at fault. So you can find someone guilty of murder but choose not to testify with your evidence, because you feel they were within their right. The game never comes forward and says “definitively, you’re right or you’re wrong with your decisions” This open ended sort of victory is oddly satisfying. It’s not the game’s version of correct, it’s my version of correct! But it’s a version of correct that made me second guess myself? On the other hand, some cases lack of real sense of closure no matter what verdict do you render. You may deduce where a final piece of evidence is or where some bodies maybe buried, but you never find out for sure and in that regard it can be maddening. For the most part, the cases are fun little mysteries in features some fantastic writing. Out of the seven, five of them captivated me and the remaining two however, fell so flat that I felt no need to explore any other possible outcomes that might have come from them. The mini games and puzzles within crimes and punishments are pretty satisfying! There are few particularly the “arm wrestling and rope bridge crossing” mini games that are infuriating but for the most part; puzzles, mini games and finding new clues all follow path of logic. There are no absurd solutions to simple problems and thankfully the game doesn’t turn into daunting pixel hunt. Don’t be mistaken, there will be times when you’ll have to hunt thru the environment just to find one little item to progress the story. The game might also force players to make deduction a bit prematurely just to advance the case. One of CNP’s biggest setbacks is its misused or disused of available resources. The custom and disguise system couldn’t be utilize to a greater effect but sadly it only comes in to play twice throughout the entire game. And Watson who should be brimming with personality and insight, largely plays a background role throughout the entire experience. He remains inhumanly upright silence and on occasion when he does talk, he doesn’t act like a capable doctor and former soldier that it should be. The game also has more that it fair share of an invisible walls and junkie environmental exploration. But who exactly is Crimes and Punishments for? I’d say that anyone who’s interested in Sherlock Holmes whether the classis version or even the new modern literation’s of the character, will enjoy themselves with Crimes and Punishments. It’s not gonna rock anyone’s world but it will certainly entertain for a while. I’d also recommend for anyone whose new adventure genre after being introduced by Telltale Games “The Walking Dead Series” but want something requiring a little more brainpower. I would not recommended to people who haven’t spent much time with an adventure genre nor to gamers only play faster paced shooter or action games. But truly, I enjoyed my time with Crimes and Punishments. The morality, judgment and deductions systems worked amazingly well for the adventure genre. The stories entertained me and I felt the sense of accomplishment when I finished the game. But the flows of the game has might be too much for more demanding gamers. At $40 Crimes and Punishments feels adequately priced especially for quality of the writing and the length of time that took me to complete it. It’s a good move in a right direction for the series and the genre, it’s just not as refined as it could be. It’s definitely a serviceable game worthy of the time of the curious and its directly targeted audience. On sale, I considered as done deal!
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
7 of 8 people (88%) found this review helpful
1 person found this review funny
19.7 hrs on record
Posted: April 19
Review - Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

"Incredible, Stupendous and Remarkable!"

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments is definitely one of the best detective games out there. The backstories for each case is unique and solid. I'm not a Sherlock Holmes fan but after palying this game, I am now. This is my first Sherlock Holmes game and by far, I have enjoyed every minute of it. From the first case to the last case, my mind was boggled and amazed. Some of the cases maybe rather obvious but there are also some where you get to really think who was culprit or how he/she did it. The game also has a lot of minigames from interrogation to looking for clues to special cutscenes that require player interaction.

+ Great Graphics
+ Great Soundtracks
+ Great Voiceovers
+ Interesting characters and cases
+ Has a lot of gameplay (a lot of minigames)
+ The mind boggling marale choices at the end of each case
+ A choice of whether you play on 3rd Person POint of view or FPS

+ Long loading screens (well, actually it's in the form of travelling from place to place)

I haven't played the other Sherlock Holmes games but for newbies to the genre, it's a good experience to start with this. I highly recommend this game to those who are really a big fan of Sherlock Holmes and to those who love detective games that does not only involve point n' click find the object game but other gameplay as well.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
6 of 7 people (86%) found this review helpful
20.4 hrs on record
Posted: February 4
Sherlock Holmes:Crimes And Punishments gives you a chance to learn world's greatest detective's life.I enjoyed a lot while doing puzzles,solving crimes,catching murderers and being Sherlock Holmes.I played 20 or 22 hours but that's quite enough time to complete game with all achievements.Besides:I miss some achievements and started game again from begining.You'll see if you play the game
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
6 of 7 people (86%) found this review helpful
50.8 hrs on record
Posted: April 1
Ive played several SH games and this is easily the best. I love the improved graphics and game play, particularly the abilty to examine the suspects via the close up eye.

It's not an action fast paced thriller but an ideal slower paced more thoughtful game , to break up the kill and run games. Has my vote - more please
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
6 of 7 people (86%) found this review helpful
18.6 hrs on record
Posted: April 27
If you've played The Testament of Sherlock Holmes you need to play this. This is the best Sherlock game, actually the best crime/mystery game I've played. The game isn't one big storyline. There's 6 crime cases in the game. This is good if you like to have stopping points to take a break. Crimes and Punishments plays a lot like Testament but better. It's not a point and click game. You can control Sherlock in 3rd and 1st person view. You get to question suspects and look for clues. Sherlock can use his instincts to find hidden clues and visualize what might have happened at the crime scene. You can go back to Baker Street (Holmes' home and lab) to do experiments and research. After you get enough clues you make deductions to form a possible answer. The game allows you to freely gather clues, talk to people and travel to different locations. It nudges you in the right directions but you have to think sometimes. If you get at a tough spot just Google a walkthrough. Crimes and Punishments is a fun and easy game to play. If you like murder mysteries and especially a Sherlock fan, you need this game!

+6 different cases
+Well developed game and written storyline
+Ability to freely investigate
+Holmes can change disguises
+Voice acting

-Some of the quick-time events can be challenging but you can always try again if you fail. There's very few QTEs but since I hate QTEs I say it's a con. But they don't make the game bad.
-I wish some of the cut scenes could be replayed. If you're playing the game and say the phone rings, if you didn't pay attention, well tough luck.

(Note: I advise you play The Testament of Sherlock Holmes before playing Crimes and Punishments. This game is a sequel but not to the storyline. But some of the characters appear in both games. It just helps make sense of certain characters.)
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
10 of 15 people (67%) found this review helpful
14.9 hrs on record
Posted: January 29
It's a very sloppy made game with a very good written story and the outstanding writing.

The game does looks fine as it's on the market of the adventure games. But this product is made badly as for a game which is was made on UE3 (at it's dusk). These people had no idea how to work with the engine. The developer can use any engine and it will be still a ♥♥♥♥. Because of that I would recommend for the team to hire the proper division of the programmers and the designers. Apparently the hungry students can't do much. This game shouldn't be in the price line as an AAA product. The above average indie product at most.

Despite the fact, I'm afraid you will not be able to find on the market another game with a such good written dialogues. It's not a eye candy, but you would like the taste.

$0.01-20.00 - Buy it! You will not regret. Anything above is a challenge.

I'm going to try the rest of their Sherlock's games now.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
6 of 8 people (75%) found this review helpful
20.5 hrs on record
Posted: December 22, 2014
Overall - recommendation

Graphics - good. Maybe my expectations were just lowered but it's a genuinely pretty game with a strong art style. I particularly like the attention to faces. Also the first person mode means that you feel a lot more immersed in the world.

Writing - solid. If you're a fan of the stories you'll enjoy the mysteries here as they're not only pretty interesting in their own write, but they also feel very much like something Doyle would have written himself.

Mechanics - fun. They can feel a touch contrived at times (press F for imagination) but they're free flowing enough to make you feel like a detective. It's worth emphasising that for the most part the mechanics compliment your own thinking and puzzle solving, rather than just doing it all for you.

Misc - voice acting is.... peculiar, it is often wooden, and over affected. The game would benefit massively from more talented voice actors, especially because you have to listen to people talk so much. It's not game ruining, but it feels like a missed opportunity for a game that works so hard to immerse you in its world. For the most part, it's not game ruining, but it damages the game's otherwise strong effort at immersion.

Final thoughts - Fancy a story driven game? But you're bored of shooting people in deserts/sewers/deserted cities? Yet you still want the good graphics and immersive perspective typical of the AAA genres? This is a good choice. Especially if you're a fan of Holmes.

Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
4 of 5 people (80%) found this review helpful
18.6 hrs on record
Posted: February 10
The best Sherlock Holmes game from Frogware and on Steam yet!
Much better than The Testament of Sherlock Holmes I'd say. Now I'm a big fan of detective type games, and this one did not disappoint.

Plot is great, the detective aspects are just as superb, and you can actually run!
Graphics are fantastic as well, really adds to the game.
And plenty of replayability if you want to persue it.
Bugs? Nonexistent, I couldn't find any at all, absolutely polished.

I honestly feel this is worth a try, and I'm one of those people that just says their opinion about it and leaves it or the reader to decide, unless it's a bad game then stay from it at all costs.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
4 of 5 people (80%) found this review helpful
17.2 hrs on record
Posted: January 12
Six different stories, not interconnected by some overall story. Fine by me. It seemed to be something like "a look into an ordinary month of Sherlock".

Visuals were very nice.

Moral evaluation of the player´s character, too.

A quite clever "neuronal system" for making deductions and decisions.

Toby :)

One minus - Watson occasionally got in my way and I had to literally push him aside which was rather annoying.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny
5 of 7 people (71%) found this review helpful
16.5 hrs on record
Posted: December 3, 2014
The best game in this series yet. Very nice UI, some good twists and dialogues. I really enjoyed this game and definitely recommend it to any point & click lovers as well as to anyone who enjoys a good Sherlock Holmes.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny