The Legendary Struggle For Catan Continues! Play the board game classic and its expansions ”Seafarers” and ”Cities & Knights” and create your own empire on Catan including individual maps and scenarios. Found settlements, build roads and prove your trading skills to become Lord of Catan.
บทวิจารณ์จากผู้ใช้: ผสมกัน (134 บทวิจารณ์)
วันที่วางจำหน่าย: 14 ส.ค. 2013
แท็กยอดนิยมจากผู้ใช้สำหรับผลิตภัณฑ์นี้:

เข้าสู่ระบบ เพื่อเพิ่มเกมนี้ลงในสิ่งที่อยากได้ของคุณ หรือทำเครื่องหมายเป็น ยังไม่สนใจ

ซื้อ Catan: Creator's Edition

 

เกี่ยวกับเกมนี้

The Legendary Struggle For Catan Continues!

Play the board game classic and its expansions ”Seafarers” and ”Cities & Knights” and create your own empire on Catan including individual maps and scenarios.

Found settlements, build roads and prove your trading skills to become Lord of Catan. With the right strategy and a bit of luck, you’ll defeat worthy competitors, such as the combative knight Sean, the shifty pirate Jean, or the cunning merchant Nassir.

Let the new, detailed graphics take you to an utterly realistic Catan, or choose the classic mode for a genuine board game feeling. Let your imagination run free and create your own Catan world including new scenarios and maps.

Find out if you really are a secret colonist; confront your rivals and become Lord of Catan!

  • Original "Settlers of Catan" rule set
  • Expansions "Seafarers" and "Cities & Knights"
  • Editor: Create own maps and scenarios and share them with players around the world
  • Two different graphic sets: realistic 3-D graphics or genuine board game mode
  • Two special scenarios: "Enchanted Island" and "Great Canal"
  • Ten smart computer opponents with individual tactics plus local hot-seat multiplayer mode
  • Numerous achievements and local game statistics
  • Tutorial and Catan Almanac
  • Developed in collaboration with Catan designer Klaus Teuber

ความต้องการระบบ

    Minimum:
    • OS: WinXP (SP3), Vista, Win7, Win8
    • Processor: Intel Pentium 4 or AMD K7; 2GHz
    • Memory: 2 GB RAM
    • Graphics: GeForce 6-Series or ATI Radeon X1000; 256 MB or higher
    • Network: Broadband Internet connection
    • Hard Drive: 2 GB available space
    • Sound Card: DirectX compatible sound card
    Recommended:
    • OS: Win7
    • Processor: 2,4Ghz
    • Memory: 4 GB RAM
    • Graphics: GeForce 200 Series, Radeon HD 4000 Series with 256MB Ram or higher
    • Network: Broadband Internet connection
    • Hard Drive: 2 MB available space
    • Sound Card: DirectX compatible sound card
บทวิจารณ์จากผู้ใช้ที่เป็นประโยชน์
25 จาก 26 คน (96%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
25.9 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 21 ตุลาคม 2014
Huge fan of Catan, so I thought I'd take a chance on this. Unfortunately, I was very disappointed.

Pros:
Visually it looks good, or at least enough for a board game based on Catan.

It handles all the rules for you so you don't have to stop the game and engage in debates. Not that you would with this version anyway (more on that later), and it includes all the scenarios and a map editor (though I haven't tried that yet).

Cons:
Controls are lacking. The map can be squirrelly to navigate. If you're using a touch-screen it's nigh-impossible. When using my Windows 8 touchscreen laptop I kept flying off into some unknown corner of the map and tapping on buttons would cause other buttons to active. The interface isn't very intuitive and it doesn't have pop-up text to help with identification.

Buggy. As others have pointed out, it's buggy and prone to crashing.

No multiplayer. This is probably the biggest negative. It's on Steam. Why not let you play with other players who own the game? I'm guessing they don't want competition to their own multiplayer subscription site, but then why even bother with this version in the first place?

Graphics options. While the graphics look decent, the lack of resolution options is very disappointing.

TL;DR: The game isn't worth the asking price. I picked it up on sale and don't completely regret it simply because I still fire it up every now and then just get a Catan fix when I can't round up a couple more players for the board game, but otherwise this one just sits in my library collecting virtual dust. The biggest disappointment is how close they are. If they fixed the bugs, tweaked the interface, and added multiplayer through Steam, it would instantly be a classic.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
12 จาก 12 คน (100%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
13.3 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 20 พฤศจิกายน 2014
Finaly I can recomend this game. I played it like one year ago and had terrible crash issues. But I decided to give it another shot and I have to say the last patch fixed those crash issues for me. Not even one crash since then. If you like Catan you should try this game.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
6 จาก 6 คน (100%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
10.9 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 20 ธันวาคม 2014
Fun game, but like most other people, this game crashes every 25 or 30 mins. The game does not include an auto save feature and having to save every 5-10 mins is annoying. Would like to see random crashes fixed or an auto save feature implemented. Seeing as these problems have been happening with this game for months, I doubt either of those are ever coming. I ended up paying less than $2 for Catan: Creators Edition during the Steam Holiday Auction and that's about as much as I recommend anyone paying for this game in it's current state. Good board game, terrible programming and support.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
3 จาก 3 คน (100%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
31.0 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 3 มกราคม
Well, it's Catan, one of the most popular European type board games in the world! The Steam version offers the same experience just without wasting time on board setup. Two expansions are included – "Seafarers" and "Cities and Knights". You can play two campaigns, custom scenarios, online scenarios (downloadable community-made scenarios) or make your own maps. You can play single player or in hotseat up to 4 players.

PROS:

– Multiple maps and scenarios
- Game editor
- Still supported by game developers (kind of)
- Takes only 1-2 hours per game

CONS:
- Not all rules are well explained in the tutorial (like what is dice stack mode and stack mode 5?)
- From trade interface it is not always clear who is trading what and with whom; it is especially a problem for beginners and in hotseat mode, when you have to be very careful about the player's name splashing for a second before the resource exchange
- Game crashes quite often and there are bugs here and there, although after the last update, it's much less of a problem than before
- Achievements do not always work
- AI is cheating. Here's why:
1) Dice rolls are not random. According to the game's tutorial and game theory, the results should be evenly distributed from 2 to 12, however that is not the case. Often, if you have settled near 6 or 8, which are the most likely combinations, you don't get those results for multiple rounds. And, when you're few points away from victory, 7 starts to fall in every or every second throw, which means that you'll be discarding you're extra resources and AI characters will be throwing robber/pirate at you (again – you loose resources)
2) AI character's are not playing to win themselves, they are playing to keep you from victory. I noticed that, in the beginning, the AI characters are never stealing from the human player, but if the human player is close to victory, they are stealing only from the human player, even if the other players have much more resources.


Suggestions for developers:
- Make dice throws random!
- Include all the expansions
- Include multiplayer

My rating:
Hotseat game with human players: 8.5/10
Scenario mode with AI players: 7/10
Campaign: 6/10
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
2 จาก 2 คน (100%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
13.0 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 4 มกราคม
Great game, but crashes many times...

I hope de development team fix the crashes.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
3 จาก 4 คน (75%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
3.6 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 20 ธันวาคม 2014
I love this game and all you can do with it, but no auto-save has caused me to lose quite a few games when it mysteriously stops working and is very frustrating. Have fun with it, but just remember to save every few turns.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
4 จาก 6 คน (67%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
1 คน เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้ชวนขำขัน
11.7 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 8 พฤศจิกายน 2014
Terrible graphics, even for a board game. The game has terrible crashing issues as well. With these crashes happening every five-ten minutes, the game is virtually unplayable, not to even mention that you can only play with bots (that are really annoying to boot). You'd be better off just buying the board game and finding/teaching some friends to play with.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
1 จาก 1 คน (100%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
18.4 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 18 ธันวาคม 2014
In the first instance, I would not recommend paying full price for this game, but, if you can pick it up on a sale for 66% or more off, then I don't think you will have much to complain about.

A lot of reviewers have complained about constant crashes, so far it has been entirely stable for, perhaps the crash issues have been patched out!?!

I have been playing the actual board game with friends for a few months and really enjoy it. This is a single player only experience, but a it does still have a lot to offer.

Other reviewers have said that they feel the dice rolling is not random, but set to deliberately hamper their development. In my experience so far the rolls still feel random enough (maybe more time invested and it will appear that way) and certainly in real life games it has felt like the dice were against me, which clearly isn't a "fix" to make things harder, that is just how "random" actually works.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
1 จาก 1 คน (100%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
8.4 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 1 กุมภาพันธ์
Fun, strategical game that is fairly easy to get used to. However, crashes often which can be a hinderance to enjoying the game.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
6 จาก 12 คน (50%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
1 คน เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้ชวนขำขัน
2,407.1 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 4 ตุลาคม 2014
I have played over 3000 games of this and maybe 20 of them crashed. It is well worth those few games to crash to have such a wonderful version of Catan with such great graphics. And besides they only crash after I've played over 10 games. So I've learned to save the game every once in awhile.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
1 จาก 2 คน (50%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
1.0 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 19 มกราคม
This classic board game is faithfully reproduced here. The Steam achievements provide concrete goals, and the online community provides friendly players willing to teach practical ingame skills!
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
79 จาก 83 คน (95%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
13.0 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 10 ธันวาคม 2013
Catan is a fun board game. It's a fun Android/iOS game. It is a HORRIBLE PC game. It crashes pretty much all the time at random. A dice roll can crash the game. Hitting 8 victory points can crash the game. Trading resources can crash the game. Anything at all can crash the game!

The campaign is unplayable because just trying to play certain levels crashes the game.

I'm really serious about all these crashes. It's no joke. What is a joke is that I can run Tomb Raider, Bioshock Infinite, Metro Last Light, etc on max settings (or close enough), but I can't run a board game.

If the game was playable, it would probably be awesome. I have the Android game also that plays just fine. Playing as a video game eases all the resource management and whatnot from the board game. The game keeps track of everything for you.

The AI cheats hardcore also. I can the AI being intelligent and trying to stop the human player(s) from winning when victory is near, but you can be at 9/10 victory points with the AI at 3/10, and suddenly no one will ever roll numbers you can use again. The game replaces difficulty with implausible dice roll outcomes. The computer also constantly offers horrendous trades and won't accept fair ones. If you have one brick and no source of brick, they will routinely try to take your only brick in exchange for a sheep you already have 8 of. Robber rolls also seem to occur more frequently when the human player(s) are past the hand size limit. It isn't impossible to beat the AI. It's just frustrating to wait turn after turn after turn and see it rolls nothing but 3s and 5s because you don't have 3s or 5s.

If you like Catan, just get the mobile/tablet game. There's no online mutliplayer in any version of the game which is sad. There's a major trend in board games coming to PC/mobile that don't have mutliplayer. There is hot seat multiplayer which works fine. I play with a friend regularly on my Android device. It's good times.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
46 จาก 48 คน (96%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
2 คน เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้ชวนขำขัน
10.3 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 18 สิงหาคม 2014
Game is a great fix if you cant get people together to play the real thing, however in its current state, the game crashes often, so if you plan on playing the campaign, be prepared to save after every turn because:


Trading causes the game to crash

Rolling the dice causes the game to crash

Builing a road causes the game to crash

Not having a settlement on a pasture causes the game to crash

Moving the robber causes the game to crash

Clicking needlessly causes the game to crash

Right click causes the game to crash

Getting a brick on a 9 roll causes the game to crash

Upgrading a city without the exact resources causes the game to crash

Building a settlement on a 3:1 port causes the game to crash

Asking your girlfriend to bring you a glass of water causes the game to crash

Petting your dog causes the game to crash

Checking your phone causes the game to crash

Writing this review caused the game to crash

Wondering why you wasted 20 dollars on a borderline unplayable game that doesn't auto save so when it crashes you get to watch 45 minuites of your life go straight down the drain causes the game to crash


Seriously, game would be fine if they fixed this ♥♥♥♥.



TL;DR: Playing the game causes the game to crash.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
39 จาก 40 คน (98%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
6.6 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 16 มิถุนายน 2014
HORRIBLE: I love Catan. Probably one of my favorite board games, however, this adaptation of Catan is HORRIBLE! If you love Catan and want to play a digital copy, play it on Xbox Arcade. It alot easier to manuever throughout the game, has speed control, and allows for multiplayer across the internet. This piece of crap only allows multiplayer on the same computer. I never write reviews, so this just goes to show how much this game is worthless. If I could get a refund from any game, this would be it! As well, this game is buggy and crashes alot!
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
34 จาก 36 คน (94%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
2.8 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 5 ธันวาคม 2013
The greatest challenge in this game trying to complete a game without it crashing first, something I've yet to achieve. Add to this the lack of online play, the terrible transaction interface and you have an unashamed cash-grab of a game. Rather buy something else...I wish I had.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
28 จาก 29 คน (97%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
8.7 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 14 สิงหาคม 2014
Constantly crashing. I bought this game when it first came out and decided to try again today hoping the bugs were fixed, but nope. Still crashes roughly every 20-30 minutes in game making the campaign nearly unplayable. If they can't fix the bugs, they could at least give some sort of auto-save so I'm not constantly losing progress in the game.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
29 จาก 33 คน (88%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
0.3 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 2 ตุลาคม 2013
No multiplayer.
Very buggy.

Do Not Buy. There are better Java versions available online for free.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
25 จาก 27 คน (93%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
0.1 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 28 ธันวาคม 2013
The developers had one job for this game, make a good version of Catan. And for the most part they did that well. With odd storyline and characters aside. There's a good amount of options and decent campaign, enough to keep you entertained while playing solo.

But now we reach the biggest drawback of this one. Absolutely no multiplayer! I don't understand how they saw a game like Catan and didn't include multiplayer. Would you leave multiplayer out of Monopoly? How about Risk? Chess? Then why the hell does this not have it!? As cool and fun the rest of the game can be. I bought this to play Catan on my PC, with friends. And the game just doesn't do that.

If you are a true Catan enthuiast or can get past some annoying voice acting and dated models, There's a lot for you here. But if you're more casual like me and just want to play with some buddies, look else where.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
20 จาก 21 คน (95%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
2.8 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 12 พฤษภาคม 2014
Catan is very fun, but this is a terrible release (As of May 12 2014). My PC blows the hardware requirements out of the water with a fresh image of windows 8.1 x64 and the game crashes randomly.

Whats worse, is starting a new game will let you play the longest, usually around 30 - 45 mins before a crash. Subsequent crashes (after reloading the game to your last save) are usually within 5 - 15 minutes. I have even tried to muddle through (since I am a serious Catan fan) and keep saving every few turns, but the game ALWAYS crashes and i'm just done.

I cant believe I had to pay money for this.

Running in any compatibility mode does not help either and even after several updates, it continues to happen. I do not recommend the Steam version of this game.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน
20 จาก 22 คน (91%) เห็นว่าบทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์
25.1 ชม. ในบันทึก
โพสต์: 29 มกราคม 2014
I only played part of the Seafarers campaign. I would have liked to play more but the constant crashing and scripted dice rolls ruin the game. The rolls seem to depend on the difficulty selected and how well the player is doing compared to the AI. It is almost comical how 7's are rolled almost immediately after the player gathers 8, 9, or 10 resources. That wouldn't be such a big issue if the AI traded competently, but they most certainly do not.

Rather than spending money on this electronic version I recommend you buy the traditional board game version. Grab some friends and beverages of choice and enjoy what is truly an excellent game and forget about this poorly executed option.
บทวิจารณ์นี้มีประโยชน์หรือไม่? ใช่ ไม่ ขำขัน